Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Tebow: Potentially the GOAT?
View Poll Results: Will Tebow go down as the GOAT
Almost for sure no matter what at this point
173 42.09%
Just finish the season strong/good bowl performance
15 3.65%
Just win heisman or go to BCS title game
23 5.60%
If they win it all this year and he wins heisman
50 12.17%
No way, no matter what
150 36.50%

11-28-2011 , 02:33 AM
People don't realize the Dolphins game was lol, the Lions game was really poor game plan and design.

The whole team is operating different since then.

TOP is up like 4 minutes, #1 rushing team in the league.

The Lions game is not a representation of how things are currently going. Lions are better and still would be like 4-5 point favorites at Denver imo. But, allowing 45 is just going to be a super rare occurrence with the way things are going.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:34 AM
Tebow had like 40 attempts against the Lions.

Since then he hasn't even come close. The entire gameplan and offensive playbook is completely different.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:36 AM
I'm pretty sure Tebow is doing this primarily because Assani pussed out and gave up his troll after one bad week.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Rat
God is really testing Tebow by asking him to play for John Fox. It's kinda like when he asked Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac.
Praise Tebow!

Quote:
Originally Posted by C-Viggity
John Fox is a ****ing ******
Let Tebow Overcome!

Quote:
Originally Posted by C-Viggity
You cannot spell tIM teboW without WIM
This is easily a top 10 post itt.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nofear3838
jfc I honestly believe that Denver could be the #1 seed, right now, in the AFC had Tebow started this entire year
Anything is possible if you put your faith in Tebow.

But seriously, I see them starting at least 3-2 instead of 1-4, so that's 2 more wins.
Broncos would be 8-3 instead imo.

Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
With two more wins a local radio show host has to get a Tebow tattoo.
lmao

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karak
Amazing.

http://espn.go.com/blog/afcwest/post...to-get-tebowed

“That’s why I Tebowed,” Carter said. “We’re all having a lot of fun.”

just kids out there having fun playing a game
A++++ This is so epic.

Is there a picture of Carter Tebowing yet? I just did a brief search on google, and I couldn't find it.

------------------------

22 rushes today by Tebow, not only does he win, but he conquers Catch-22 in the process.

Yossarian somewhere, would be very proud.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Seadood228
Jets and Raiders pretty good afaik. Not as good as the Broncos ofc.
Jets are pretty bad and that game was also a thursday night @ Denver when the Jets played the sunday nighter before that.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:39 AM
completely different offense imo, surprised teh raiders by showing something new, go back to scoring 16-17 ppg.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ikestoys
completely different offense imo, surprised teh raiders by showing something new, go back to scoring 16-17 ppg.
So.. the anomaly is the one where Denver scored 2x their next highest (I don't disagree).. but not the one where they allowed 2x their next highest?
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:42 AM
Just to be clear, everyone on skype knows that i think tebow is a hof person and has goatish intangibles.

First of all its extremely lol that people think you can judge tebow in a 6 game sample, which is an extremely small sample highly affected by variance. The funniest thing is when people say "tebow just wins games" even though his team has been winning despite his lackluster performances. whether people think tebow is good or bad seems to be a sick way of filtering whether people know about football or not. The defense has been goating ever since the qb change, esp von miller. Besides the defense, they have also been carrying tebow through a pretty easy schedule along with some good RB performances (as chim said "#1 rushing team in the league") and key special teams T/O's in his wins. I love tebow as a person but hes one of the worst QB'S in football, objectively speaking.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:42 AM
Denver probably won't score 38 again.. but they probably won't allow 45 either.

The whole game is different. They won't surprise teams like the Raiders got surprised.. but they also won't throw the ball 40 times and not have any TOP.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AcTiOnJaCsOn
Just to be clear, everyone on skype knows that i think tebow is a hof person and has goatish intangibles.

First of all its extremely lol that people think you can judge tebow in a 6 game sample, which is an extremely small sample highly affected by variance. The funniest thing is when people say "tebow just wins games" even though his team has been winning despite his lackluster performances. whether people think tebow is good or bad seems to be a sick way of filtering whether people know about football or not. The defense has been goating ever since the qb change, esp von miller. They have been carrying tebow through a pretty easy schedule along with some good RB performances (as chim said "#1 rushing team in the league")/ key special teams T/O's in his wins. I love tebow as a person but hes one of the worst QB'S in football objectively speaking.
There is something to be said about Tebow making life a lot easier for the RB's, though. I don't think its coincidence McGahee is beasting all the sudden.

Like I said all along.. if Tebow could complete those easy throws he'd be very good.. and 60% would make him elite.

Sadly right now he can't do either.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
So.. the anomaly is the one where Tebow scored 2x their next highest (I don't disagree).. but not the one where they allowed 2x their next highest?
[ ] Tebow plays defense

I could really give a ****ing **** about the the lions game being anomaly. It's really tangential to the conversation and stupid nit to make. Tebow is 5-1 is about as relevant as Tebow has a negative point differential. He still blows regardless.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ikestoys
[ ] Tebow plays defense

I could really give a ****ing **** about the the lions game being anomaly. It's really tangential to the conversation and stupid nit to make. Tebow is 5-1 is about as relevant as Tebow has a negative point differential. He still blows regardless.
Tebow clearly has an impact on the defense. TOP matters. Not turning it over matters. Field position matters.

After they stopped the 40 attempts all of those things have considerably improved.

TOP is like 4 minutes better now. Denver went from something like -8 to +4 in TO differential (can't remember exact stat but think that was it).

I'm not saying Tebow is great or anything.. but you are really going about this the wrong way.

At least you basically admitted your PD argument was irrelevant.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:51 AM
Also, while he is really terrible at throwing the ball.. he clearly is impacting the RB's. #1 running game in the NFL since he took over. That matters too.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:51 AM
AJ your post tells that YOU'RE the one who knows little of footballl. Perhaps the defense has played better because they NEVER have a short field to defend? Perhaps the running game has come alive because Tebows legs take away from keying on the backfield?

Quote:
Jets are pretty bad
The Jets are not bad any way you slice it. Their record is +.500 and they are good by all advanced metrics. Try again. Oh yeah they had 6 LESS HOURS TO PREPARE than the Broncos oh noes.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Tebow clearly has an impact on the defense. TOP matters. Not turning it over matters. Field position matters.

After they stopped the 40 attempts all of those things have considerably improved.

TOP is like 4 minutes better now. Denver went from something like -8 to +4 in TO differential (can't remember exact stat but think that was it).

I'm not saying Tebow is great or anything.. but you are really going about this the wrong way.

At least you basically admitted your PD argument was irrelevant.
Bolded is most important. It's a lot easier to defend 80yards vs. 30, but that appears to be too difficult for some to understand.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Denver probably won't score 38 again.. but they probably won't allow 45 either.

The whole game is different. They won't surprise teams like the Raiders got surprised.. but they also won't throw the ball 40 times and not have any TOP.
Yea, I think this is on point. Okay, New England could rock them pretty hard, but they're averaging 44 rushing attempts per game since that Detroit loss. (lol)

For perspective, coming into this week Houston was #1 in the NFL at 35 per game.

I can't speak for all Denver fans, but personally I'm just enjoying the ride and have zero expectations with Tebow. I don't think he can throw worth a damn, and I think he's a clear dog to make it as a QB in the NFL. He's still fun to watch/root for though, and beating the Chargers/Chiefs/Raiders all in the last month is sweet regardless of how it happened.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ikestoys
[ ] Tebow plays defense

I could really give a ****ing **** about the the lions game being anomaly. It's really tangential to the conversation and stupid nit to make. Tebow is 5-1 is about as relevant as Tebow has a negative point differential. He still blows regardless.
Oh wow.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Tebow clearly has an impact on the defense. TOP matters. Not turning it over matters.
Its easy to do both of these things when you dont throw the ball that often. INT's are very highly correlated with the volume you throw the ball (think about it the less you throw the ball, the more surprising it is to the defense, and the more often it should work). If tebow threw thirty times a game or so and turned it over as less as he did, it would be 100x more impressive.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Seadood228
Perhaps the defense has played better because they NEVER have a short field to defend
except thats not true.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Seadood228
Perhaps the running game has come alive because Tebows legs take away from keying on the backfield?

Fair point, tho considering they have to run the ball a lot since tebow is the woat pocket passer, its not like nfl defenses wont be able to defend a gimmick strategy like the option better when its not new and a surprise to nfl defenses. Its not even close to sustainable longterm until he is a better pocket passer.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:09 AM
AJ,

Obv it would be more impressive if he threw the ball a ton and didn't turn it over.

But he isn't turning it over. That matters. It doesn't mean he is a top tier QB right now. But it does matter as far as winning games goes.

I think Tebow is still a dog to be an NFL QB 5 years from now. That being said it is certainly possible we just don't understand all the impacts he has on the game and he may raise equity in unique spots. Running games may always be better around him.. turnovers may always be lower.. field position may always be better.

Those things do matter. With Tebow in this tiny sample size those things have been improved.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AcTiOnJaCsOn

except thats not true.
Yes it is. Tebow's lone turnover was in the end zone, returned 100 yards.. Everything else has been a punt. He has not left them with a short field all season.

Quote:
Fair point, tho considering they have to run the ball a lot since tebow is the woat pocket passer, its not like nfl defenses wont be able to defend a gimmick strategy like the option better when its not new and a surprise to nfl defenses. Its not even close to sustainable longterm until he is a better pocket passer.
I guess when all else fails, let's go back to the same old argument.

Tebow really does get the haters mad.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:26 AM
i love how haters are all "tebow is WOAT pocket passer" and try to evaluate him like they would brady or rivers and pretty much ignore all the things around him that he makes better...it's like, oh he only has 130 passing yards??? obv not sustainable obv. how long must he sustain it before it's not "unsustainable" anymore? 10 games? 20? 5 years?
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
AJ,

Obv it would be more impressive if he threw the ball a ton and didn't turn it over.
I should have been a little more clear. INT percentage is highly correlated to passes attempted. The TD/INT ratio is very negatively correlated to passes attempted. If he passed more these numbers would increase and decrease substantially respectively. Its kind of like TS% in basketball (though its impossible to quantify how similar it is), the higher the volume someone can maintain the same TS%, the more its exponentially impressive. Obv when you take 35 shots in a basketball game its way harder to keep a TS% at a certain percentage as a bulk shooter than someone who takes 5-10 shots a game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Those things do matter. With Tebow in this tiny sample size those things have been improved.
I agree it matters, but i disagree with how much he has an impact on these things. When there is a QB change, it sends the message that anyones job is on the line. That combined with non guaranteed contracts, all the sudden people are going to give a lot more effort. I agree that tebow brings some leadership/intangible qualities that are hard to quantify, but i think that still the gap between bringing tebow into to the qb position - bringing a replacement level qb in is a lot smaller than people would like to admit based on the factors referenced earlier.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Seadood228
AJ your post tells that YOU'RE the one who knows little of footballl. Perhaps the defense has played better because they NEVER have a short field to defend? Perhaps the running game has come alive because Tebows legs take away from keying on the backfield?
Was going to post exactly this.

5 star post Seadood.


I love it when Tebow gets those haters mad.

Don't worry, ActionJacson, Tebow is praying for you:

Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:34 AM
i'm curious...starting with the miami game, if orton was still the starter, what do u haters think denver's current record would be? I think michael irvin just said it best on nfl gameday. he read in the bible "He hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise." All of you are just confounded by tebow b/c he's so unorthodox and you don't know how to properly evaluate what you're seeing. At the end of the day, I evaluate it by W-L. 5-1. I will pray for you all.

Last edited by elstunar; 11-28-2011 at 03:43 AM.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Seadood228
Yes it is. Tebow's lone turnover was in the end zone, returned 100 yards.. Everything else has been a punt. He has not left them with a short field all season.



I guess when all else fails, let's go back to the same old argument.

Tebow really does get the haters mad.
First of all i dont get why me loving tebow as a person/ his intangibles is mutually exclusive with me objectively evaluating how good of a QB he is.

Anyway, "short field" is really subjective and therefore youre claim is conveniently really hard to falsify. Your argument would be a lot better if you said like chim that field position has improved instead of "they never had to deal with a short field," Which obv isnt true.
Quote:
Originally Posted by elstunar
i'm curious...starting with the miami game, if orton was still the starter, what do u haters think denver's current record would be?
well your falling for a common fallacy called being results oriented. Orton is a way better QB so id say that if the roles were reversed and orton relieved tebow (so it motivates the team in the same way) that his expectation to win each game is substantially higher, hence being way more likely to be 5-1 or 6-0.
Tebow: Potentially the GOAT? Quote

      
m