Quote:
Originally Posted by CalledDownLight
I have a rant with non-rhetorical questions and suggestions on draft threads.
I love drafts. I have enjoyed the few I was a part of and enjoy reading others that take place, but its pretty unbearable for me that few finish at all, none follow the deadlines set by the OP, and I have never seen any that actually get judged or anything like that.
I feel like if there was an actual enforceable participation standard then they would progress so much better. I think some system that includes a ban, probably after a warning or two, should be instituted so that those that sign up cant just disappear to the detriment of the other participants and forum as a whole. I know that I would join more drafts (and invest significant time into them) if they were certain to run to completion at the speed designated before the draft. I feel like others would too.
Do others not feel the same as I do? Is everyone else really fine with the fact that every draft dies or hits a dead period at some point?
I agree with your attitude towards the drafts, and with dkgojackets points as well.
Of course people are pretty busy, but its not to hard to pay general attention to the draft thread and the spreadsheet every so often to see if youre up soon. If youre busy for parts of a draft its easy to pm people pick lists or post that you need to be skipped in order to keep the draft moving. If for some reason one is so busy that they cant do these things, they just shouldnt participate.
As for what can be done about it, I think there should be a list of people who get chronically skipped for drafts and a stricter selection process for who can draft. Then if someone does get skipped 2-3 times in a draft they should just get booted and someone lurking can take over. Also think that the amount of people and rounds can be cut down. Also the commish has to be good and on top of things for a draft to succeed. There have been a few drafts recently where the commish got skipped multiple times, which just sets a bad example and is a bad look. All the hockey drafts we have had where dwd was commishing ran really smoothly and got completed. Some other ideas would be to perhaps have all the participants in a skype group so that its easy to see whos online and who isnt. Not exactly sure which of these ideas should be implemented, perhaps all of them. I just know the status quo is pretty unacceptable, especially considering that SE supposedly prides themselves on drafting.