Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
kc, I guess the problem I'm having here is that Theon has way more than enough motivation to turn on Ramsay. We didn't need that potential topped off with a little good ol' Westerosi raping.
I'm being put in the position of defending rape culture (nath_headnod.jif), but **** it, I don't like putting kids gloves on art cuz feelings. Why I think the rape scene isn't pointless, purely shock value, etc:
Regardless of what RR intended, or what Benioff intended (though given Benioff's literary work I find it highly probable this is his intention), I think this is a fair deconstruction of Theon.
First, Theon accepts Ramsey's abuse because he subconsciously believes he's deserving of it. His own father loathed him, the Starks were his real family, and he betrayed them to appease his own wicked dad. On top of that, he murdered innocent children.
Thus, his reasons to turn on Ramsey aren't as strong as one would think. On some level, he's accepting of his own personal abuse. It's his penance. And that's really all he's seen.
But now he is witnessing something far worse: a powerless woman being raped by Ramsey. A woman he once considered family no less.
So in essence, in the logic of the Theon plot, yes, witnessing Ramsey torture someone besides himself is necessary for Theon to turn on him. Did it need to be rape? Probably not, but that is the most likely thing to happen between Ramsey and Sansa and is the most consistent with Ramsey's character. And because it is such a depraved act, it is all the more jarring, and all the more likely to snap Theon out of it. I don't think seeing Ramsey torment her verbally is going to get it done.