Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
Battle of the Bastards was GARBAGE. That single episode necessarily destroyed all conceivable positive interpretations of Sansa, leaving us with only (1) she's an idiot who means well (i.e., didn't tell Jon about the army from the Vale because she's too dumb to mention it or didn't know if it was coming at all, in which case she knowingly let Jon, and the North with him, march to death while that question hung in the air), or (2) she's evil and wanted to guarantee the crown for herself by letting him die before claiming the victory and, with it, control of the North (i.e., she's a mini-Cersei).
The problem is neither one of those is congruent with the character. The only conclusion one can reach is the showrunners gave the writers idiotic instructions that damaged the show and wrecked Sansa.
ya i don't think it's 1 or 2
probably more going on there, like:
- Jon might not want to work with Littlefinger, she seemed sketched out about them together, but i don't even know why ... did Jon have any real thoughts on LF? he knows nothing
- the Knights of the Vale prob more keen on the plan as executed, rather than joining the battle from the start (yeah they'd have to do as ordered, but as this season has finally told us, ppl think what they think about events)
- like you say Sansa might not known if they were coming or not, or if they were coming to help or hurt (a LF back-stab would have been brilliant tbh)
- some other stuff i already forgot
but it was probably 95% dumb drama to deceive the audience, which is a lot of seasons 6-8 unfortunately