Quote:
Originally Posted by Willd
Almost managed to blow it is a bit of a stretch. After the third try I don't think there was any point at which they weren't massive favourites. Probably should have gone on and got the bonus point but they were never in any real danger of not winning.
I'm curious what people's thoughts on the red card are though. I lean on the side of thinking that it was probably correct. Had Tuilagi actually made any attempt at all to use his arms in the tackle then the fact that North was so low would be enough mitigation to make it a yellow or possibly even just a penalty.
Just re the red card - I discussed this today as it goes with a former international referee who works in the game. If no arms are used (they clearly weren't here) and there was force (not sure what the proper phrase is but it clearly was here) and contact is made with the head or neck then it's 100% a red card, so this was the correct all. All referees and coaches were given a flowchart to cover these kind of situations before the world cup and Eddie Jones is talking crap - he knows it was 100% a red card.
Frankly, if he had caught North flush he'd have left the ground in the ambulance and - given his history - that may have been his final game. This is exactly the sort of challenge that the IRB is trying to cut out as that was insanely dangerous.