Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion

10-22-2018 , 07:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
What would it take for UCF to get in? Obviously win out is a requirement so that they can say they haven't lost in 2 years. Bama winning out and ND losing is required as well. Does another UT + OU loss, a Clemson loss, and tOSU/PSU/Michigan having two teams with 2 losses of the three get there?
Feel like they still need more than that.

Think they would be behind a 1-loss Clemson and 1-loss ND. Not even sure they would be in front of a 2-loss LSU.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 09:57 AM
If Purdue runs the table to finish at 10-3 with a B1G championship victory over a 1 loss Michigan or Ohio State, I wonder can they sneak in over a 2 loss team (potentially Oklahoma/Notre Dame/Georgia) with a convincing win in the B1G championship
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 10:00 AM
Pretty much 0% chance that Purdue gets into the playoffs. I don't know that we'll ever see a 3-loss team make it in, especially not when the 3 losses are to 3 unranked teams.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 10:41 AM
While I don't think it's technically impossible, it would require chaos the likes of which have never been seen before.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 10:55 AM
UCF AD wrote a letter out or something about the unfairness

They've really skyrocketed to most annoying team/fan base and I look forward to their regression back to nothingness
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 10:56 AM
For 10-3 Purdue or 13-0 UCF:

Pac-12 can kill itself pretty easily. In fact, might even be more likely than not to produce a 3 loss champion.
Stanford / Wazzu / Washington all play a round robin. If they all go 1-1, then Pac-12 north is done. If one of them goes 2-0, that team could easily lose another game. (to like Cal for example, where UW is only -10 somehow, or in the Pac-12 CG).

Oregon/Utah loser is also out, Utah could also easily lose.


Big-12 can also cannibalize pretty fast, but no guarantee a 2 loss champ is behind UCF or 10-3 Purdue. Like if Texas loses @ Ok State this weekend, then rips off wins over #13 WVU, @ Texas Tech, v ISU, @ KU and then top-10 Oklahoma again, they're probably in.

Similarly, if OU loses @ Texas Tech but beats KSU and @ WVU and then 11-1 Texas, they're probably in for sure over those teams as well. Best case scenario is probably for Texas to lose twice (@ Ok State and @ TTU for example) then win the title by beating OU or WV for the second time.


In the SEC you want just Bama to emerge, which shouldn't be too hard. (LSU gets thrashed by Bama, and loses @ ATM for good measure, who is also very likely to lose a third game to Miss / Miss St / Auburn).

Kentucky will probably lose 2 more and be a non factor. UGA/Florida loser is probably out, and the winner could lose another 1 before the SECCG just to be safe. Ideally to FSU or GT (not impossible)

ACC is hard, most likely is just Clemson comes out undefeated and that's your second team. But they still could lose a late game (@ FSU, @ BC, v USCe) then the title. Only other contenders are Miami/VT/BC who all play each other. NC State loses a 2nd just to be sure.

Notre Dame has losable games @ Northwestern, @ USC v FSU and v Cuse. A favorite to lose 1, though losing 2 is less likely. Losing the last one @ USC would be a crusher if they've already lost 1.


Purdue gets Wisconsin and Iowa at home, both of whom still also play Penn State and could bounce the Pedos. Michigan / Ohio State is a nice elimination game too, Purdue prefers Michigan to win since they already thrashed Ohio State, and would get to beat 11-1 Michigan in the B1G CG.


Purdue could end up with wins over #2 Michigan, #6 Ohio State, top-25 Iowa / Sparty / Wisconsin and maybe even top-25 BC if BC if BC beats 2/3 of Clemson VT and Miami.

They'd have won 10 in a row, and their first 3 losses were beginning of the season by 8 total points.

The could make it for sure. It helps that they can eliminate so many contenders, unlike UCF who basically has to count the B1G as getting a slot one way or another.



For the sake of simplicity say Oklahoma, Clemson and Bama win out and nobody else in those conferences is in contention.

Utah loses a late game or two and then wins the Pac with 3 or 4 losses. Notre Dame loses to FSU and USC. Wisconsin/Iowa/Purdue finishes 8-4 and wins the B1G West and then wins the title game decisively over Ohio State who finishes 10-3 (loses @ MSU then beats Michigan).

UCF would be in there for sure, and that's not even that much chaos.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:04 AM
Suuuuch a huge bummer that Houston lost that shootout to Texas Tech. They have so much legitimacy with the win over Arizona in back to back years and the two wins over Oklahoma and Louisville the year before that and Ed Oliver name recognition.

Cincy has the win over UCLA and South Florida beat GT and Illinois. Bummer Cincy lost to Temple (who beat Maryland)

Not sure if it's better for UCF to face down 11-0 USF in the last game of the season again, or if they'd prefer Houston to win and go 11-1 and be ranked for the title game. (i.e. who are they rooting for this weekend?)

If Pitt somehow finishes 7-5 that would be helpful.

Undefeated has some cachet, so I suppose they want to play 8-2 Cincinnati, then 11-0 USF (probably ranked ~15 by then) then 10-2 Houston.

Reeeeeeally would be sick if Navy could pull a miracle and beat ND both knocking of ND and making that game more legit too in spite of Navy's awful record
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by eyebooger
...or maybe not.
They will be by next week after someone loses the Cocktail Party.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by younguns87
UCF AD wrote a letter out or something about the unfairness

They've really skyrocketed to most annoying team/fan base and I look forward to their regression back to nothingness
Yeah that's Danny White. He's completely insufferable and convinced they deserve to get in if they win out because "nation's longest winning streak" yes your fortunes this year should be determined in part by how you fared in prior years. (Somehow this logic was inapplicable last year coming off a losing season and two-years removed from an 0-12 campaign.)
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by maxtower
Y'all are crazy. A 1-loss B1G team is making it in 100% of the time. The only way they get left out is if there are 4 other undefeated teams from the P5. The only thing the Purdue loss means to OSU is that they can't lose another game the rest of the way.
Penn State beats Michigan. (possible)
Michigan beats Ohio State. (possible)
Iowa loses to somebody. (likely)

In that case it's incredibly likely, almost 100% that the B1G is not in the CFP.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldenBears
For 10-3 Purdue or 13-0 UCF:

Pac-12 can kill itself pretty easily. In fact, might even be more likely than not to produce a 3 loss champion.
Stanford / Wazzu / Washington all play a round robin. If they all go 1-1, then Pac-12 north is done. If one of them goes 2-0, that team could easily lose another game. (to like Cal for example, where UW is only -10 somehow, or in the Pac-12 CG).

Oregon/Utah loser is also out, Utah could also easily lose.


Big-12 can also cannibalize pretty fast, but no guarantee a 2 loss champ is behind UCF or 10-3 Purdue. Like if Texas loses @ Ok State this weekend, then rips off wins over #13 WVU, @ Texas Tech, v ISU, @ KU and then top-10 Oklahoma again, they're probably in.

Similarly, if OU loses @ Texas Tech but beats KSU and @ WVU and then 11-1 Texas, they're probably in for sure over those teams as well. Best case scenario is probably for Texas to lose twice (@ Ok State and @ TTU for example) then win the title by beating OU or WV for the second time.


In the SEC you want just Bama to emerge, which shouldn't be too hard. (LSU gets thrashed by Bama, and loses @ ATM for good measure, who is also very likely to lose a third game to Miss / Miss St / Auburn).

Kentucky will probably lose 2 more and be a non factor. UGA/Florida loser is probably out, and the winner could lose another 1 before the SECCG just to be safe. Ideally to FSU or GT (not impossible)

ACC is hard, most likely is just Clemson comes out undefeated and that's your second team. But they still could lose a late game (@ FSU, @ BC, v USCe) then the title. Only other contenders are Miami/VT/BC who all play each other. NC State loses a 2nd just to be sure.

Notre Dame has losable games @ Northwestern, @ USC v FSU and v Cuse. A favorite to lose 1, though losing 2 is less likely. Losing the last one @ USC would be a crusher if they've already lost 1.


Purdue gets Wisconsin and Iowa at home, both of whom still also play Penn State and could bounce the Pedos. Michigan / Ohio State is a nice elimination game too, Purdue prefers Michigan to win since they already thrashed Ohio State, and would get to beat 11-1 Michigan in the B1G CG.


Purdue could end up with wins over #2 Michigan, #6 Ohio State, top-25 Iowa / Sparty / Wisconsin and maybe even top-25 BC if BC if BC beats 2/3 of Clemson VT and Miami.

They'd have won 10 in a row, and their first 3 losses were beginning of the season by 8 total points.

The could make it for sure. It helps that they can eliminate so many contenders, unlike UCF who basically has to count the B1G as getting a slot one way or another.



For the sake of simplicity say Oklahoma, Clemson and Bama win out and nobody else in those conferences is in contention.

Utah loses a late game or two and then wins the Pac with 3 or 4 losses. Notre Dame loses to FSU and USC. Wisconsin/Iowa/Purdue finishes 8-4 and wins the B1G West and then wins the title game decisively over Ohio State who finishes 10-3 (loses @ MSU then beats Michigan).

UCF would be in there for sure, and that's not even that much chaos.

After last season, I'm realistically skeptical that would even get UCF into the top ten. It's unlikely both the SEC and Big 12 won't have anyone else with like 2 losses, plus even in your scenario the committee could just take 10-2 Michigan or 10-2 Notre Dame.

OTOH, UCF's schedule *does* have some advantages over last year's stretch run; Temple, Navy, Cincinnati, and @ South Florida are all reasonable live bodies or better with the bookend games on Thursday or Friday nights so plenty of opportunity for them to "be seen". I suppose it also *may be* possible the committee essentially gives them credit for beating Auburn in the bowl.

Meh, I'm not going to get my hopes up until I see UCF placed anywhere seeming to have a chance of making the top 4.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddBoiler
If Purdue runs the table to finish at 10-3 with a B1G championship victory over a 1 loss Michigan or Ohio State, I wonder can they sneak in over a 2 loss team (potentially Oklahoma/Notre Dame/Georgia) with a convincing win in the B1G championship
I drink a lot of Black and Gold kool-aid Redd, but I can't even drink that one.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Namath12
Yeah that's Danny White. He's completely insufferable and convinced they deserve to get in if they win out because "nation's longest winning streak" yes your fortunes this year should be determined in part by how you fared in prior years. (Somehow this logic was inapplicable last year coming off a losing season and two-years removed from an 0-12 campaign.)
Which part of this would you be doing differently, were you in his position?
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:31 AM
The problem for UCF is that their strength of record is almost never going to be top 5.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddBoiler
If Purdue runs the table to finish at 10-3 with a B1G championship victory over a 1 loss Michigan or Ohio State, I wonder can they sneak in over a 2 loss team (potentially Oklahoma/Notre Dame/Georgia) with a convincing win in the B1G championship
no
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:39 AM
Thanks for the info. It might not be as crazy as I initially thought then.

It's also kind of cool to have people hating on the school. It was always such a bad and irrelevant program that anytime they started doing well everyone else did the underdog pity love thing where they said "aw good for them!" and now we've got people being annoyed and mad at the audacity of thinking they've done well enough to deserve an opportunity for something bigger.

I've watched USF get national recognition back in the mid/late 00s, think they were hot **** now, and then fall back into awfulness (they even stopped doing the USF/UCF rivalry game because they thought it was beneath them once they got ranked a couple of years in a row) so I know that this type of success is fleeting for a smaller program and you shouldn't get in over your head with your year to year expectations. It's just been fun to watch over the last couple years.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldenBears
For 10-3 Purdue or 13-0 UCF:

Pac-12 can kill itself pretty easily. In fact, might even be more likely than not to produce a 3 loss champion.
Stanford / Wazzu / Washington all play a round robin. If they all go 1-1, then Pac-12 north is done. If one of them goes 2-0, that team could easily lose another game. (to like Cal for example, where UW is only -10 somehow, or in the Pac-12 CG).

Oregon/Utah loser is also out, Utah could also easily lose.


Big-12 can also cannibalize pretty fast, but no guarantee a 2 loss champ is behind UCF or 10-3 Purdue. Like if Texas loses @ Ok State this weekend, then rips off wins over #13 WVU, @ Texas Tech, v ISU, @ KU and then top-10 Oklahoma again, they're probably in.

Similarly, if OU loses @ Texas Tech but beats KSU and @ WVU and then 11-1 Texas, they're probably in for sure over those teams as well. Best case scenario is probably for Texas to lose twice (@ Ok State and @ TTU for example) then win the title by beating OU or WV for the second time.


In the SEC you want just Bama to emerge, which shouldn't be too hard. (LSU gets thrashed by Bama, and loses @ ATM for good measure, who is also very likely to lose a third game to Miss / Miss St / Auburn).

Kentucky will probably lose 2 more and be a non factor. UGA/Florida loser is probably out, and the winner could lose another 1 before the SECCG just to be safe. Ideally to FSU or GT (not impossible)

ACC is hard, most likely is just Clemson comes out undefeated and that's your second team. But they still could lose a late game (@ FSU, @ BC, v USCe) then the title. Only other contenders are Miami/VT/BC who all play each other. NC State loses a 2nd just to be sure.

Notre Dame has losable games @ Northwestern, @ USC v FSU and v Cuse. A favorite to lose 1, though losing 2 is less likely. Losing the last one @ USC would be a crusher if they've already lost 1.


Purdue gets Wisconsin and Iowa at home, both of whom still also play Penn State and could bounce the Pedos. Michigan / Ohio State is a nice elimination game too, Purdue prefers Michigan to win since they already thrashed Ohio State, and would get to beat 11-1 Michigan in the B1G CG.


Purdue could end up with wins over #2 Michigan, #6 Ohio State, top-25 Iowa / Sparty / Wisconsin and maybe even top-25 BC if BC if BC beats 2/3 of Clemson VT and Miami.

They'd have won 10 in a row, and their first 3 losses were beginning of the season by 8 total points.

The could make it for sure. It helps that they can eliminate so many contenders, unlike UCF who basically has to count the B1G as getting a slot one way or another.



For the sake of simplicity say Oklahoma, Clemson and Bama win out and nobody else in those conferences is in contention.

Utah loses a late game or two and then wins the Pac with 3 or 4 losses. Notre Dame loses to FSU and USC. Wisconsin/Iowa/Purdue finishes 8-4 and wins the B1G West and then wins the title game decisively over Ohio State who finishes 10-3 (loses @ MSU then beats Michigan).

UCF would be in there for sure, and that's not even that much chaos.
This seems correct, but you definitely have a different definition of "not even that much chaos" than I do.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by eyebooger
This seems correct, but you definitely have a different definition of "not even that much chaos" than I do.
You need a lot of stuff to go your way, but you could do it with barely any 7+ upsets, and there are lots of shots to get upsets.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Holliday
After last season, I'm realistically skeptical that would even get UCF into the top ten. It's unlikely both the SEC and Big 12 won't have anyone else with like 2 losses, plus even in your scenario the committee could just take 10-2 Michigan or 10-2 Notre Dame.

OTOH, UCF's schedule *does* have some advantages over last year's stretch run; Temple, Navy, Cincinnati, and @ South Florida are all reasonable live bodies or better with the bookend games on Thursday or Friday nights so plenty of opportunity for them to "be seen". I suppose it also *may be* possible the committee essentially gives them credit for beating Auburn in the bowl.

Meh, I'm not going to get my hopes up until I see UCF placed anywhere seeming to have a chance of making the top 4.
I don't think they are gonna take a 10-2 Michigan team that lost in the last game of the season. It's not like the Ohio State or Bama teams that didn't win their conferences but finished 11-1.

10-2 Big-12 team is tough, b/c they would have ended the season by winning their conf, but Texas could easily lose 2 games then win the conf and finish 9-3. I agree if Oklahoma or Texas loses this weekend then wins out they are in over UCF.

Pac-12 would require chaos to NOT cannibalize itself, they're all but dead already.



SEC could easily finish with no two loss teams. Right now you have:
Kentucky, UGA and UF.
LSU and ATM.

Assuming LSU loses to Bama, they and ATM play each other, so the loser has 3 losses. If ATM wins that game, they are heavily favored to pick up a third loss.


Winner of the UGA/UF game picks up a second loss in the last game of the season, the SECCG. UGA also plays @ Kentucky, v Auburn, v GT. Florida also plays Mizzou, USCe and FSU.

Kentucky plays @ Mizzou (touchdown dogs), @ Tennessee and @ Louisville. Nobody is really taking them seriously.

ACC can't produce a 2 loss non champion except NC State or BC, and they're both heavily favored to lose 1+ regardless
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:54 AM
Usually at this point of the season, the thing that's hard is "team x might lose but then that would vault team y ahead of UCF" but this year you have TONS of team Y type teams that are pretty good, could pull upsets, but aren't a threat to jump UCF.

Like Mississippi State, Auburn, Utah, USC, Colorado, Washington State / Stanford loser, Cal, Texas Tech, Iowa State, Oklahoma State, West Virginia (possibly), TCU, Purdue, Penn State (if they lose a 3rd game), Michigan State, Wisconsin (if they lose a 3rd game), etc. etc.

BC/Miami/VT round robin loser... Florida State could wreck havoc for UCF: They play Clemson, @ NC State, @ ND, BC and Florida. If they can win a couple games against that tough slate, that would do wonders

Imagine if FSU beats Clemson, NC State, ND and Florida and loses to BC who also loses a 3rd game
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 11:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
If OSU wins out, they go to the playoffs

A 1-loss Big 10 Champ OSU is getting in almost always

I guess Bama, Clemson, ND and Oklahoma that wins out, including avenging their one close Texas loss could keep OSU out, but the odds of all 4 of those winning out is very low

Like every year, there will be more chaos and more losses

tOSU still basically controls their own Destiny, and may full control it depending on how the committee feels about the big 12
what if bama loses to lsu and then lsu or george wins the sec with 1 loss?

then bama and lsu/georgia make it along with clem and nd.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 12:01 PM
Can't think of much that can save UCF at this point. They tried with their schedule, but Pitt ended up not very good and UNC game was canceled but they're awful anyway. Had they played those 2 and they were having a season like NC State is, they'd have more of an argument.

Probably mandatory that USF wins out and the matchup to end the regular season between 2 undefeateds might get them some pub. Then hammed a 2-loss Houston in the title game. Still probably a 0.5% chance even if all that happens.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofball
I think it's time to revisit this post I wrote: https://actuarygambler.blogspot.com/...-iowa-was.html
Just to be clear, I completely agree with your thesis. It's just that the people who actually decide these things did not appear to see it that way and I expect their attitude to continue.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldenBears
Suuuuch a huge bummer that Houston lost that shootout to Texas Tech. They have so much legitimacy with the win over Arizona in back to back years and the two wins over Oklahoma and Louisville the year before that and Ed Oliver name recognition.

Cincy has the win over UCLA and South Florida beat GT and Illinois. Bummer Cincy lost to Temple (who beat Maryland)

Not sure if it's better for UCF to face down 11-0 USF in the last game of the season again, or if they'd prefer Houston to win and go 11-1 and be ranked for the title game. (i.e. who are they rooting for this weekend?)

If Pitt somehow finishes 7-5 that would be helpful.

Undefeated has some cachet, so I suppose they want to play 8-2 Cincinnati, then 11-0 USF (probably ranked ~15 by then) then 10-2 Houston.
USF is one of the worst undefeated teams ever, no idea how they're ranked. Before last week UConn was 0-5 vs FCS schools with all 5 losses by 30+ points and 4 losses by 40+ points. USF beat them by 8. Beating an 11-1 Houston whose only loss is TTU would be way more impressive.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 12:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Holliday
rolls eyes and opens up the archives all the way back to 2015. sees no B1G championship game participation. wonders why we're making this comparison before resigning to dismissive wanking motion.

Clemson's toughest regular season opponent is Duke and ND's isn't much better. Any losses they pick up will be "bad". Polls had you well ahead of them last week when you all had the same record, so yes you'll pass them if they lose given you'd be the one beating ranked opponents down the stretch. Oklahoma is 27% to win out and Texas is 2% (that low number means their probably not going to make it all the way to the CCG with their current ranking), and even in that 29% combined probability you're so scared of there's a decent chance you pass them anyway. Sure you got slaughtered at Purdue but Oklahoma got taken to OT by the US Army at home, and Texas lost to Maryland.

Things might get tight if BOTH Clemson and ND run the table, but that's only a 22% chance and would still leave SEC and *you* with that 29% chance of a Big12 school that would be a consideration. I'm not even going to consider your "2 SEC teams" theory because that's just your paranoia talking (although possibly we could bet on that one!).

*Ohio State wins out
*78% of the time one of Clemson or ND loses. You're in +78%
*of the remaining 22%, 71% of the time no Big12 team ahead of you runs the table, so You're in +15% = 93%
*of the 29% of the time Texas or OK wins out, let's say committee picks you half of the time, so 22% of 29% times 50%, so You're in +3% = 96%

So I've got you as 96% to make it should you win out. I just don't know why you're so glum. Well, other than the raped by Purdue thing.
2014 osu was analogous to last years bama. they were the defending champs who lost a super fluky game to the only strong team they played all year, a very strong msu team.

2017 bama were defending champs and played one good team all year and lost to a very good auburn.

lol at 2 sec teams as paranoia. it happened last year! hell, if bama is smart they will lose to lsu so they dont need to beat themselves up in an extra super tough sec title game.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote
10-22-2018 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aurora Tom
Penn State beats Michigan. (possible)
Michigan beats Ohio State. (possible)
Iowa loses to somebody. (likely)

In that case it's incredibly likely, almost 100% that the B1G is not in the CFP.
Sorry misread the part about 1-loss in his comment.
Post week 8 NCAAF rankings/discussion Quote

      
m