Quote:
Originally Posted by GeoffRas22
Hey Nath, can you believe it's been 10 years?
Ugh, yeah, I remember. I didn't even have to click the link to know what you were talking about. Special shout out to the commissioner who decided to "not get involved" even though that's literally the entire ****ing job of the commissioner.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Onlydo2days
Didn't Cian Fahey say that Cam was #2 QB in the NFL before the season?
Remember that next time you hear someone citing his work as a reason Kaep is a top 20 QB.
I'll take someone who actually watches every snap and breaks it down over the casual-fan who saw half a dozen overthrows in highlights and is pretty sure his opinions are gospel.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
I am admittedly not a fan of Cam, I think hes an arrogant prick (all i need is body language)
I didn't know Nolan "Fake Smile" Nawrocki posted here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Melkerson
Well your original statement sounded like you were some how concluding that Tannehill was significantly better than Moore because how AIDSy Cutler is playng. If all you're saying is that Tanne is better than Cutler, there's not much argument to be had. I think the question is how much and we probably disagree a little on that.
Well, now it's debatable whether Cutler or Moore is better, because Cutler has been awful, but I don't think it's debatable that Tannehill is.
I mean, Moore had one season of significant experience, and he put up a middling ANY/A on low volume mostly chucking it to Brandon Marshall. He was 27 then and he's 33 now. I know the NFL's braintrusts are often bad at correctly evaluating QBs, but I think the evidence Moore is a "good QB" is primarily dependent on overrating small samples or taking samples from a long time ago. Similarly, I think most people formed an idea of Tannehill early on and haven't refined it, even though his performance has improved every year. (By the way, each of Tannehill's last three seasons have been better than Moore's best season.)
Even saying that, it's important to remember that stats don't always tell the whole story, because context matters so much in how they were generated. (Witness the difference between Jared Goff from year one to year two, and how much has changed in that time period. Did he just suddenly become a top-10 QB? I doubt it.)
