I haven't mentioned the rings at all.

Nope. You don't get it both ways. If winning superbowls matter for Brady, then Ben's do too. Woo! Ben is better than Payton!!!

Brag: This guy disagrees with everything I've ever said.

Goodie: Let's put down ever cliche WRT to football and why I love Brady.

God this thread is always annoying. How many times have we come to this argument and its always about intangible and rings vs actual performance. I'm pretty sure of all people I'm the most weary of straight stats arguments. But when it comes to Peyton I think its fine. If he doesn't have the intangibles then I have no idea what it is. He calls the OL calls, the WR calls, the QB calls, he is the first to the photos on the sidelines. I mean, Peyton has forgotten more about football in the past week than I have ever known.

Manning is like mr. intagible aka david eckstein.

they are part of the barometer of overall team quality though so it is kind of implicit

edit: and there is no case for brady w/o them, not that i'm saying you are trying to make one

The thing is, ten years ago this stuff would have bothered me. But now, rolls right off. You see, Boston is title town now. We've had more success in the last ten years in sports than I dare say any town ever has. I love being from Boston and as much as it shouldn't, the jealousy by yahoos like you make me smile.

JFC you are embarrasing. I bet you are the reason Boston is title town USA.

Let me guess, you feel you are better than me b/c you are a Boston fan..........................lol.

If only I were born a few hundred miles more north. Then I could live a happy life knowing I am at the epicenter of ownage. Thank you for opening my eyes to this and I bow to all of New England and their lives being complete do to their sports franchises. I will now crawl into a hole and cry for 7 days to represent the 7 championships of Boston in the past decade.

Child please. This is basically your entire argument.

Pats and Sawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwks lost yesterday so you got sand in your vajayjay so you revert to this nonsense.

If the two were on the same team, Brady is always Peyton's backup.

Well, this thread is doesn't matter of course. In the whole scheme of things, which QB is better is pretty meaningless in life, but it's fun to argue.

However, not to derail the thread but you've clearly stated that you think cheating on a girlfriend or wife is perfectly okay so yeah, I have little to no respect for you or your posts.

Not always. They'd let Peyton play the regular season and then put Brady in for the playoffs ldo.

The problem here is that my post is correct, we are title town and we have had more success than any other town in the past ten years. You being upset about it doesn't make it not true. Your jealousy is noted and puts one more smile on my face.

I can't help that, for too many years I was the one jealous of other towns.

Guys I'm a fan of

The Yankees, Red Sox, Pats, Steelers, 9ers, Cowboys, and just about every other good team in every league. All my teams ROCK, therefore I'm better than you and you can suck it. If team Y wins the title next year, I'm a fan of that team too. I'm a fan of winners and cause they win, I'm ****ing better than you.

Change Red Sox to Angels ldo.

Title Town lolololololol

Peyton is the GOAT, discussion is over.

Ad hominems rule dude!!!

I too would be jealous of towns in which you don't reside.

Costanza Theorem states that If Goodie disagrees with everything I've ever said, everything I've ever said must be correct.

I'm not saying this at all. My god, you do realize we're talking about Sports here, right? Of course it's a nice distraction and brings joy (mostly lately) and heartache (the rest of my life) but it's still just games. I clearly don't think I'm personally better than anyone else because my teams win.

And I've been a Boston sports fan my whole life and will never support a different team. I'm not a fair weather fan and watched the Pats and died with them when they were horrible.

19-1

Point is you are bragging cause you are a fan of those teams some how you are better than all of us. Nobody gives 2 ****s if you like Boston teams and they are title team USA. We all know that ****, and you pointing it out doesn't some how make us feel worse. OMG, you are so lucky you are a Boston guy and you are a fan of all these teams with titles. OMG, OMG, OMG. You wouldn't point out title town USA, if you think we wouldn't care. Honestly we are debating Manning vs Peyton and you bring up the Celtics, and Sox titles into the argument...wtf. This argument was dumb enough as it is, but you drag in the rest of Boston to some how strengthen things or prove something. LOL.

I am not sure what the argument here is. If Goodie is arguing that Brady > Peyton right now than lololololol. If Goodie is arguing that Brady's career > Peyton's career, than lolololol since Peyton has been better, but also has 1.5x the attempts as Brady.

Really? Because I support my sports team and sometime irrationally defend them? My god you take sports WAAAAAAAY too seriously. My opinions about games that other people play should not in any way reflect what kind of human being I am. You people need to lighten up.

irrationality is for women...take that **** outta here