Quote:
Originally Posted by Alpha Fish
he's #1 in completion %, Y/att and Y/G and #2 in passer rtg on that list (and that includes his "irrelevant" years)
but I guess he's just not HOF material
He barely played those 5 years. If he had to play any time other than when he was on a good team with HOF WR's/RB then his #'s would probably look a lot different.
People can say "Oh Giants benched him" but he played with elite WR's in AZ and they still drafted Matt Leinart.
I don't even necessarily mind him getting in because I don't care who is/isn't in the HOF, but I think there will be a lot of guys that don't get in who are better than him.
Yeah, he had injuries in the middle of his career but so have a lot of guys. And they didn't get to play with Holt, Bruce, Faulk, Fitz, Boldin in their primes.