Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread

12-18-2023 , 04:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madlex
Might be a stupid question but how is it not clear if the portal players are going to play, a couple hours before the game starts?

Are you saying they traveled to the game with the team and haven't told anyone if they're going to play or not?
Some guys enter the portal and are very clearly gone

Other guys enter the portal but keep practicing, and I assume leave the door open for a return. I assume the coach knows whether or not they'll play, but for "strategic" reasons doesn't tell the public, and it's difficult to find information online. especially for games like this where nobody gives a fk. Given the line moves when info comes out, it seems clear that Vegas is also often guessing. Like right up to gametime I could find zero information about whether the WKU linemen were gonna play. I assume if you went and scouted the walk thrus or practices or talked to guys in person you could suss it out, but there just isn't enough money to be won with that information so people don't really go out of their way to do it. I will check guys' twitters or instagrams or message boards once in a while to see if I can pick up any clues, but yeah usually you just don't really know.

I assume the coaches would generally rather play guys who aren't transferring so that they can get next year's players more experience, but if a guy is totally blowing it, you maybe put the better player back in there (like what is happening with Veltkamp right now)
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 04:13 PM
For games like this, it's sort of the same principle that won a ton of money on colorado/tcu and baylor/texas state

You have coaching changes, guys opting out, some teams taking it seriously, some teams not, guys failing classes and losing eligibility, etc.

You should have much less faith in your pregame priors and rely more on the first quarter eye test. Very plausible that the team on the field is just totally different than the team your pregame projections are based on
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 04:54 PM
Veltkamp is balling (13/13) off the bench but the offensive line looks worse than colorado

He just got sacked in 2 seconds on 3rd and 10, ODU rushed 3 guys and two of them sacked him

run plays to the runningback are impossible
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 06:27 PM
hahahha oh boy

in my face


odu might lose straight up


it's wild bc the themes haven't changed. they're still getting incredible penetration every play and WKU cannot run the ball, but every screen or pass into the flat goes for 60 yards if the QB is able to get the ball out
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 07:33 PM
Bowl season is so great. That was incredible
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 09:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FellaGaga-52
Who do you think the best 4 teams are? So that means drop all the bullshyt and write down the name of the best 4 and most qualified teams. Qualified means, generally and nearly strictly, teams who are undefeated or have 1 loss. From there, all the candidates are on an even footing, whether with one loss or none ... and the body of work and current status of the team rules.

12-1 in some spots is much better than 13-0 in others, obviously. There is a reason why all the CFP teams are about 2/1 to win it except Washington, who is 7/1. What's up with that? If Georgia played Washington, what would the line be? And if Georgia was in they would also be about 2/1, not 7/1.

A team can generally eliminate themselves by losing twice, but not by losing once, and certainly not by losing once to a playoff team. Georgia and Bama are in the same boat there as the two most deserving teams. Michigan had ten byes to go 10-0 and here they are again. Washington beat everybody and their sister by one score or slightly more. They're Cinderella. If they line up against Georgia, it's about half of the TCU fiasco last year. Every position is a mismatch. 12-1 > 13-0 many, many times.

The qualified candidates based on all factors are Michigan, Bama, FSU, Washington, Texas, Georgia. The most distinguished of those are Michigan, Texas, Bama, and Georgia. You have to drop the "But they're undefeated" argument in the hierarchy several notches.

Georgia out here is about like UCLA out in the '74 NCAA Tournament because USC or somebody beat them in the conference championship game. So I say it's bogus, a bummer for the spectacle of it, where an obviously qualified team is eliminated by some lesser qualifier.
Oregon was a greater than 1 TD favorite over Washington. Washington won. You want to make it a beauty contest but winning should matter. BTW what your odds mean is Washington is the +ev bet.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-18-2023 , 09:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madlex
Might be a stupid question but how is it not clear if the portal players are going to play, a couple hours before the game starts?

are you saying they traveled to the game with the team and haven't told anyone if they're going to play or not?
aren't you envious of a free trip to charlotte this time of year?
they probably still thought it was being played in the bahamas
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 04:02 PM
Marshall:
QB Fancher out
RB Ali playing
WR Coombs out

UTSA:
Trey Moore, best defensive player is out

QB Frank Harris just got declared out a few minutes ago
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 09:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldenBears
Marshall:
QB Fancher out
RB Ali playing
WR Coombs out

UTSA:
Trey Moore, best defensive player is out

QB Frank Harris just got declared out a few minutes ago
This is pretty much why bowls are nearly in-game-only for me at this point.


UTSA without Harris is in pretty bad shape, but not as bad as starting a muppet legacy guy with a 0 to 6 td to int ratio. Like, oh no; we don’t have our sack monster, i guess we’ll just have to settle for interceptions.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 09:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by REDeYeS00
aren't you envious of a free trip to charlotte this time of year?
I don't know about Charlotte any time of the year ��

If I had to choose between playing in a meaningless bowl and going home for the holidays to spend time with family and friends like 90% of other college students do, that doesn't sound like a difficult decision to me. If participation wasn't basically required for anyone who wants to be on the team the next year I wonder how many players would actually show up for those bowl games?
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 10:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madlex
I don't know about Charlotte any time of the year ��

If I had to choose between playing in a meaningless bowl and going home for the holidays to spend time with family and friends like 90% of other college students do, that doesn't sound like a difficult decision to me. If participation wasn't basically required for anyone who wants to be on the team the next year I wonder how many players would actually show up for those bowl games?
I think you might be underestimating how much they like playing football but are definitely overestimating how much they want to be like other college students.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 10:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madlex
I don't know about Charlotte any time of the year ��

If I had to choose between playing in a meaningless bowl and going home for the holidays to spend time with family and friends like 90% of other college students do, that doesn't sound like a difficult decision to me. If participation wasn't basically required for anyone who wants to be on the team the next year I wonder how many players would actually show up for those bowl games?
If you took a poll who knows, but I used to play football because I loved playing football

I would probably want to play and it wouldn’t be meaningless to me. And we need to define meaningless because if it’s defined as anything other than a playoff game then all of these group of 5 players signed on for meaningless games their entire careers.

We shouldn’t totally discount other things, some guys such as that third stringer from Minnesota might be starting his first and only game in his career. And it’s in a pro football stadium in a game televised by ESPN. It was phrased as this guy has virtually no reason whatsoever to play. Depending who he is and how much he likes football that might not be the case at all.

Maybe he’d like some glory before working 30 years as an insurance salesman :shrug;
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 10:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScotchOnDaRocks
If you took a poll who knows, but I used to play football because I loved playing football

I would probably want to play and it wouldn’t be meaningless to me. And we need to define meaningless because if it’s defined as anything other than a playoff game then all of these group of 5 players signed on for meaningless games their entire careers.

We shouldn’t totally discount other things, some guys such as that third stringer from Minnesota might be starting his first and only game in his career. And it’s in a pro football stadium in a game televised by ESPN. It was phrased as this guy has virtually no reason whatsoever to play. Depending who he is and how much he likes football that might not be the case at all.

Maybe he’d like some glory before working 30 years as an insurance salesman :shrug;
yeah the nfl guys who are going to make millions in the league couldnt care less about these games but the 25 year old 7th year senior who put off entering the workforce for three years so he could play more ball is probably getting pretty hyped for these games.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 11:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hellmuth was right
yeah the nfl guys who are going to make millions in the league couldnt care less about these games but the 25 year old 7th year senior who put off entering the workforce for three years so he could play more ball is probably getting pretty hyped for these games.
And you make zero sense, certainly future NFL players wouldn’t care so much since they have big games left in their future.

So why did the guy stick around for 7 years assuming he could have graduated earlier. But then he has no reason to play after not playing all these years? Lol

And Holliday basically said the same thing and y’all jizz over his posts (except he couldn’t see the FSU thing coming)

Send me another dummy, I have no more use of this guy
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 11:13 PM
Marshal may want to keep an eye on that Cephus fellow.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-19-2023 , 11:39 PM
Lol, UTSA coach literally high-stepping onto the field to call TO after that turtle-coach run play w 50 seconds.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-20-2023 , 12:19 AM
4th and 2 marshall lines up for a 43 yard fg instead of going for it. then scramble into sneak position and hard count to try to draw them offsides. UTSA doesn't jump, and instead of taking a timeout marshall just takes a 5 yard penalty to make it a *48 yarder.* kick is good, but marshall guy was offsides, so now it's a 53 yarder. They kick again and miss. lmao
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-20-2023 , 01:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by madlex
Might be a stupid question but how is it not clear if the portal players are going to play, a couple hours before the game starts?

Are you saying they traveled to the game with the team and haven't told anyone if they're going to play or not?
This star running back just opted out at halftime after getting 92 yards, so yeah.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-20-2023 , 01:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScotchOnDaRocks
And you make zero sense, certainly future NFL players wouldn’t care so much since they have big games left in their future.

So why did the guy stick around for 7 years assuming he could have graduated earlier. But then he has no reason to play after not playing all these years? Lol

And Holliday basically said the same thing and y’all jizz over his posts (except he couldn’t see the FSU thing coming)

Send me another dummy, I have no more use of this guy
are you actually re.tarded or just pretending to be re.tarded?

my post was agreeing with your post.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-20-2023 , 01:44 PM
FSU got job bed. This is all a farce.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-20-2023 , 09:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hellmuth was right
are you actually re.tarded or just pretending to be re.tarded?

my post was agreeing with your post.
Lol was it?

My bad buddy, was hungover all day and exhausted from giving people the back of my hand in other forums

My apologies!
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-21-2023 , 06:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScotchOnDaRocks
Lol was it?

My bad buddy, was hungover all day and exhausted from giving people the back of my hand in other forums

My apologies!
Alcohol destroys brain cells. If you wanna continue to stay one step ahead of GB stop now!
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-21-2023 , 08:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
Alcohol destroys brain cells. If you wanna continue to stay one step ahead of GB stop now!
Yeah I try and save what I have left
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-22-2023 , 12:46 AM
This Syracuse-South Florida game has been such a good bowl game!
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
12-23-2023 , 10:42 PM
Bold strategy by Utah to play a defense and punting game against a B1G West member.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote

      
m