Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
I think that's the same same criticism we've been seeing against this year's Bucks. That this is the Bud regular season special, their best player is easy to guard against in the playoffs. They haven't done anything over the past couple of years to prove otherwise. After Game 1-3, weren't most people writing off the Bucks for exactly this reason?
Yeah this is what I mean and I also don't understand the comparison to Lebron vs Warriors in 2015. That was a historically lopsided series in terms of overall talent, not just because it was Lebron + scrubs on one side, but because the Warriors were a dynasty-caliber team. The only reason why people thought the Cavs had a chance was because of Lebron and people were pricing in the possibility that the Warriors weren't maybe quite as good as they'd been (which they largely disproved the following season). This year's Bucks are far closer to the Hawks in 2015 than to the Warriors in 2015. They are a top-heavy team whose 2nd/3rd best players aren't even clearly all-star caliber.
Wasn't DeMarre Carroll in 2015 roughly as good as Donte DiVincenzo, who's out for the series? Carroll also did play all 4 games, though I'm sure he wasn't 100%.
Playoffs aren't just about having the best player - Jokic >>>> Anyone on the Suns for instance but the Nuggets still got swept. And if you look at the BPM of top 4 players in minutes, they are comparable:
2015 Hawks
Korver: 2.8
Millsap: 3.4
Horford: 4.1
Teague: 2.9
Combined: 13.3
2021 Bucks
Middleton: 1.3
Giannis: 8.8
Jrue: 3.5
Lopez: 0.0
Combined: 13.6
CP3's exceptional career and Booker's scoring arsenal have confused a lot of people into thinking that the Suns have top-tier players, but neither is a clear top-15 player and I think Millsap and Horford in 2015 were probably roughly as good relative to the league as CP3 and Booker have been this season.
Edit:
Btw, I'm not saying the 2015 Hawks are as good as the 2015 Suns. But to the extent that Bud teams struggle in the playoffs, it appears to be largely because they outperform their natural talent level in the regular season and Bud doesn't coach very well in the playoffs (at least compared to the regular season. It's not because their best player isn't as good as the other team's best player - Giannis was also better than anyone on last year's Heat. And the Bud factor is something that applies to both the 2015 Hawks and the 2021 Bucks.
If you wanna just sort by BPM/PD/SRS then sure you can get that answer I guess. But like I said, the Hawks were considered a regular season team that ended up struggling in rd 1 and rd 2. Wall actually broke his wrist in gm 2 of that 2nd rd, I remember thinking he stays healthy and the Wiz win that series but we'll never know.
Again, the Nets (pre-harden news) were +4.5 at home tonight, they were being given something like 38% chance to win this series (and this is with Harden/Irving returning possibilities) The Cavs were a 65%ish/-200 fav to win their series and that is without HCA.
Also, who says the Bucks have done nothing? They almost made the finals a few years ago and that was with playoff useless Bledsoe instead of Jrue. That is a big gap in previous accomplishment than beating the Wizards with John Wall having a broken wrist.
It just isn't the same thing, the massive gap in the odds of the two examples you cited shows that. They're not even in the same ballpark for level of difficulty. If you wanna go even further, the Nets WITH their big 3 AND HCA were about the same level of fav vs the Bucks as the Cavs were vs the Hawks and Love out/Kyrie banged up going into series. That is a massive gap.
I would say it is closer to LeBron/GS where he gave them a fight. I don't think GS 2015 was a historically great team, I think Klay/Dray had not reached their peaks yet and they had no playoff experience. Luckily for them, KD died, LAC/SA ate each other then Hou upset LAC and Kyrie/Love were dead in the finals so they had the easiest road to a title possibly of all time. That is more my opinion I guess but even odds reflect that as well. Unless you think they were massively underrating how good GS was, but I really don't.
Again, all of this is pretty moot unless Harden reinjures himself fast.
Last edited by Onlydo2days; 06-15-2021 at 07:27 PM.