Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
Meh, if KD had of chipped this year and won a couple more, people would have used hindsight to say he was actually better than LeBron since 2017.
Sure people would say stuff like this, but those would be mostly from the same people who already believe this.
Quote:
Much like they did in 2016 with LeBron over Curry when Curry was winning MVPs and LeBron won when down 3-1.
Again, most people who were saying this were the same people who already believed that Lebron was better than Curry. People who genuinely thought Curry had clearly overtaken Lebron as the best player were going on about injuries and stuff.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nucleardonkey
I'm saying guys like you make up a whole narrative about so and so is or is not the goat based on a game he might as well have won. It's other overreach of the analysis relative to the evidence that i'm getting at.
You should pay more attention because I'm doing the exact opposite. I'm saying there is no grand narrative to be had here and was just warning against hyperbolic assessments of the game. I already conceded that Kevin Durant was great, just not as impressive as his high scoring total would suggest. And the ridiculous narratives are almost entirely in the opposite direction - in a conference semifinals where KD and Giannis were roughly as good as each other and both performed not far from expectation, we saw no end of narratives around how you can't win with Giannis as the best player, while many people proclaimed KD as the best player and wondered if he should be ranked higher in the all-time ranking.
Also, didn't you go on about Westbrook and how KD should have a bunch more rings after KD's career game? Maybe try to follow your own advice about about not overreaching relative to the evidence.
Last edited by candybar; 06-20-2021 at 03:59 PM.