Spector kinda rules. I thought he was early 2nd round material.

Really not getting the Tyler hate.

I need to think for awhile.

See Pudge's post.

I have to go soon - if flyingrat/cwice doesn't pick can someone take take?

nvm, he's here.

Oh well, headed off to happy hour now. I thought I'd have to defend that pick a little but it looks like if anyone is gonna rip it it'll be now that I'm gone, lol.

wow, seriously, **** you guys.

It works with your studio. Also, I think I just daggered Wrane.

You'll have to PM me who pudge is talking about, because I'm drawing a blank. I still don't see much difference between he and petty. I personally like petty a lot more, but doesn't change the fact that aerosmith was one of the hugest bands of the 80s with hugely successful rebirth in the 90s. And Tyler was a key drivin force in that.

Does the split song writing really cost him that much? I get that sole writing credit is a big deal, but I think it gets a tad overrated. Sure, townshend's writing is important, but it's clear from his bland solo work that the rest of the band wa keybin filling in the gaps and making the songs work. To a much lesser extent, same goes for the heartbreakers. And if it really means that much, yorke seems spewey.

Seriously, it would have created magic with my boy.

tilt-picking now.

I think the sole vs. shared songwriting argument is definitely a case by case basis. Some songwriters are garbage solo and somehow become magical when in a room w/the right cast of characters (see the many failed side projects over the course of music history).

I'm not sure w/Tyler, maybe I believe Petty is better as an individual because he's much more of a musician, and his situation seems like star + supporting cast, whereas Tyler seems pretty closely linked w/an undrafted guitar player.

Got the wings of Heaven on my shoes

I'm a dancing man, I just can't lose

A+ pick ldo. Would have been so sick with Benny Andersson but quickie writeup here.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XtqJ1...eature=related

Great pick - I was considering him as early as round 2. The guy is a hit machine.

Gibb is sick value here. There's no arguing with the commercial success plus I can't think of anyone else who has written disco music that I actually enjoy listening to. Saturday Night Fever is pure genius.

Also, Jive talking is one of my favorite songs of all time.

Gibb also has written hit songs outside of disco - Heartbreaker (R&B, recorded by undrafted) and Islands In The Stream (country, pair of undrafteds).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dq6YmSVAOG8

^favourite bgs song.

I know who undrafted I now, and I agree it's lol for Tyler to go ahead of him. However, it's dishonest calling petty much more of a musician than Tyler. Tyler is a crazy talented multi-instrumentalist.

Not really sure why I'm putting this much time into defending Tyler; I'm not a big fan of his music. But I do think biases are selling him short.

The lip-synching in the Stayin' Alive video is bad. Probably a good pick though.

I kinda hope Wrane takes the BPA so I don't feel obligated to, because I want to take someone else.

edit: Looks like he did. Sweet.

I'd say very good pick.

They were supposedly really good live too I think?

He already did...?

finally.

this, although i think if you're looking for a female vocalist there's a better one out there (that could easily be undrafted)

also liked the timbaland pick, works so well

Jagger is sick value here. Hugely underrated IMO as a singer, half of one of the all time rock song composing teams, one of the most charismatic and energetic front men ever ...

WTF with Grind drafting Richards in the first round and not taking Jagger in the third (or even the second) round?

I would 100% be down for this. I actually had a draft idea somewhat similar to that, and well this one, where we pick albums to make a label. I thought it would be pretty fun, but this one has been great so far. I think this may go down as the most popular draft in SE for a while.