Quote:
Originally Posted by pokeriseasy
I really don't see how the 50-45 is absurd. There was no round Penn clearly won. Any round that you can give to BJ it was close, and since it was close it means you can give it to Edgar. Do I think it was 5-0 for Edgar, no, but the only round I can say with confidence I gave to BJ is the 1st round but even that was a competitive round, the 2nd round was a tossup from there on out I though Edgar won.
At some point during the 1st round the fight began to remind of the Dominick Cruz/Brian Bowles fight. One guy ducking in and out mixing up his angles and the other just standing in the middle of the ring trying to counter punch. Of course Penn was far more succesful than Bowles who was essentially just a punching bag in that fight.
I'm really surprised Penn didn't press the action more and never attempted a takedown. The one thing that comes from Penn losing is it makes the LW division a lot more interesting. I think now Florian should get a title shot against Edgar and Penn shold fight Maynard with the winner getting the next title shot. Also Penn's aura of invicibility is gone, which should make his future fights more competitive.
This is absurd
Penn dominated the first two rounds, and you really aren't watching very closely or you don't know what you're talking about if you don't think Penn easily outlanded Edgar the first two rounds.
Edgar had a lot more bouncing in the first two rounds, and BJ hit him in the face a lot more. BJ clearly won both rounds.
Edgar landed 5 of 29 punches to the head in round 1. BJ landed 16 of 39. BJ threw more, landed more, and landed at a higher percentage.
Edgar landed 6 total strikes in the second round. He was 6/44, and only four shots to the head connected. Penn landed 17/49 strikes in that round. Once again, Penn threw more, landed more, and landed at a higher percentage. How exactly was it a 'tossup'?
Watch the fight without commentary and really actually watch to see which punches land. BJ clearly won the first two rounds.