The most popular incorrect answer is Chris Sale. With that run support and his fantastic streak of double digit strikeout games, he'd seem to be a pretty safe answer. But he only has 4 wins so far, just missing for this question.
Gary Wise
hard2tel
NDfan
Priptonite
royalblue
txdome
Our two next-most popular incorrect answers were selected by 4 players each, and both pitchers are currently on the DL. Noah Syndergaard, unfortunately for him, is gainfully employed by the New York Mets and their medical staff. I'll let you insert your own joke here, and he has 1 win this season.