Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
181 30.47%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
316 53.20%
Therapist
8 1.35%
George Mikan
5 0.84%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.54%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
13 2.19%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.37%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.51%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.52%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 3.03%

05-27-2017 , 05:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by estefaniocurry
Can someone explain to me the case for the league being better now than it was in the 80s and 90s? There's clearly a change at the end of the 70s, early 80s when salaries skyrocketed (I don't know exactly when it was) with the corresponding increase in professionalism, but in the late 80s and early 90s there was already plenty of money on the table.

I watch ball now I see a lot of sloppy play with the ball, everyone spread out around the arc, no one inside, no one stopping penetration, not much post play. It's clearly different, and part of it is clearly the defensive rule changes. But, it seems much easier to get off a shot. There's clearly a preference now for mobile players and shooters, but there's not much ball movement, just 1-2-3 shoot, and too many open shots.

Summary, I don't see it as self evident that Lebron faces the kind of competition that Jordan did. Watching him just go to the basket at will against Boston makes that idea hard to accept, as good as Lebron is (someone will say: Tristan Thompson). The reason us old people love Iverson so much in spite of his Kobe like statistics is that we remember that little tiny guy getting to the hoop through a sea of Oakley minded defenders. Same for someone like Bird (Lebron's game reminds me most of Bird's, he's just a better athlete).
Just using actual logic instead of the weird reverse-logic of "people were tougher and better for some unknown reason decades ago than they are now", it's self-evident that more worldwide interest in the league, higher salaries, more access to basketball at a younger age, increased competition due to all of this, smarter body and sports science, and smarter coaching and management would lead to better play.

"I see a lot of sloppy play with the ball" is likely not true in comparison with the '80s-'90s.

"Everyone spread out around the arc" - yes this is generally a good thing, because unlike morons in the '80s-'90s, coaches of today have often done some simple math and found that 3s > 2s. They've even done complex math and found that, say, a 33% chance of hitting a 3 is better than even a 49% of hitting a 2.

"No one inside" is not true.

"No one stopping penetration" is of course not true, but if it there is truth to it then it's due to better offensive play, perhaps more screens (don't know), less aggressive defense allowed, generally more complex tactical plays drawn up as well as athleticism to trigger penetration, and sometimes defenses "allowing" penetration in order to prevent 3s. Will get to this below.

"Not much post play" is true to an extent, partly because of rule changes, and partly because the types of shots generated from post play are often not efficient. There may be less incredible big men available at the moment, just due to variance (we're not living in an era where Shaq, Duncan, Hakeem, Robinson, and Ewing are all active)? I don't know.

Some teams such as the Spurs have gone against a lot of this, intentionally. They have focused on some more post play, zagging while the league is zigging. When they played the Rockets, their goal seemed to be to never allow open 3-pointers. If a Rocket could successfully penetrate, fine, the Spurs big men were waiting near the basket with their arms straight up in the air, refusing to foul and send them to the line.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by w_alloy
Jordan had a combined record of 68-96 his first two seasons (1-6 in playoffs), while Lebron was 77-87. Which of those is more impressive? Also Jordan had three years of college while Lebron came straight out of high school.
Jordan dropping an NBA record that hasn't been broken since for points scored in a playoff game, in his second season after sitting most of it out because of a broken foot, is indeed far more impressive than LeBrons non-making the playoffs record.

Thanks for playing!
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerb iLL
Jordan dropping an NBA record that hasn't been broken since for points scored in a playoff game, in his second season after sitting most of it out because of a broken foot, is indeed far more impressive than LeBrons non-making the playoffs record.

Thanks for playing!
seems like Jordan slacked for the rest of his career
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:15 PM
So , he did reach the playoff anyway ...

Quote:
Originally Posted by w_alloy
Jordan had a combined record of 68-96 his first two seasons (1-6 in playoffs), while Lebron was 77-87. Which of those is more impressive? Also Jordan had three years of college while Lebron came straight out of high school.
Ho wait now you are saying LeBron had more difficulty to make the playoff with a better team record because he faced tougher competition , so he should be excused for missing the playoff , but explaining Jordan lost in first rounds vs the celtics ( championship caliber) that does not count for explaining his lost.

Ok ...

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 05-27-2017 at 05:21 PM.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fallen Hero
seems like Jordan slacked for the rest of his career
If slacked is going for 6/6 and being considered the greatest ever I'd hate to think what you'd call LeBron 3/4 and being carried off the court for pussy pains
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerb iLL
If slacked is going for 6/6 and being considered the greatest ever I'd hate to think what you'd call LeBron 3/4 and being carried off the court for pussy pains
that scoring record though
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:43 PM
At least LeBron can ignore his father without killing him

I guess he lacks the

Spoiler:
killer instinct

Last edited by THAY3R; 05-27-2017 at 05:52 PM.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 06:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by THAY3R
At least LeBron can ignore his father without killing him

I guess he lacks the

Spoiler:
killer instinct
Oh yeah LeBron had some teammate blowing out his mom's pussy on the reg and didn't put an end to it.

Cucked by a teammate while being a loser in the finals, after getting sonned in his first finals by a 35 year old journeyman.

Sounds like best ever material to me
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 06:12 PM
MJ scoring a meaningless amount of points while losing pathetically in the first round seems pretty worthless tbh
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 06:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mullen
MJ scoring a meaningless amount of points while losing pathetically in the first round seems pretty worthless tbh
Agree, now imagine the meaningless record of your team if you don't even reach the playoffs, twice....

But hey some think it is better to not reach the playoffs than lose in the first round of the playoffs vs the champions...

Am I right?
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:02 PM
Did some tinkering with my model and improved the inputs and hypothetically if Cavs win this series AND LeBron plays well he'll move up to 6th all-time

If they win and he's carried he'll drop from 9th to 13th

If they lose he drops from 9th to either 16th or 17th depending on how Durant does

Big series for his legacy
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by estefaniocurry
Can someone explain to me the case for the league being better now than it was in the 80s and 90s?...
Who do you think would win a 100m race between Carl Lewis and Usain Bolt in their primes?

How about a 100m freestyle between Mark Spitz and Michael Phelps?

Interesting how every sport with a timer consistently proves that athletes are getting better over time, yet people want to act like team sport athletes were somehow better back in the day.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheNoodleMan
Who do you think would win a 100m race between Carl Lewis and Usain Bolt in their primes?

How about a 100m freestyle between Mark Spitz and Michael Phelps?

Interesting how every sport with a timer consistently proves that athletes are getting better over time, yet people want to act like team sport athletes were somehow better back in the day.
plenty of track and field records have stood for 20-30 years or longer.

ill take peak tiger over any of the scrubs now on the pga tour. ill take peak bonds over any hitter currently in the mlb. and likewise with MJ.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:19 PM
He asked about the league being better, not the top players.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:24 PM
i didnt read all of his post. thats a stupid argument.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:30 PM
Canadians are truly the nut low NBA posters.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:35 PM
They balance it out with their HAWKEY knowledge
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
I am just laughing when I read people saying Jordan rodman and pipen could not play defense and loose vs the warriors.

I see , the player today can do it but all the great before could not adjust ,zzzzz

On one side we say LeBron has a weaker team then Jordan and they did beat the warrior but somehow , with a better team surrounding Jordan, they couldn't beat the warriors .

Pure logic right there.
Well the did add Kevin ****ing Durant...
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:54 PM
Would be funny tho if LeBron would reach out for westBrook to counter Durant if lebron lose this serie
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by muttiah
Canadians are truly the nut low NBA posters.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DarkOne
They balance it out with their HAWKEY knowledge
Impressive.
Great points right there to help your side.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 08:27 PM
Dude. You have lebron and kobe as close. You are by far the most wrong poster itt.

Even gerb aj and woody dont go that far.

You dont get to critique smarter posters arguments.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Would be funny tho if LeBron would reach out for westBrook to counter Durant if lebron lose this serie
CLE equity goes down if they get Westbrook
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Dude. You have lebron and kobe as close. You are by far the most wrong poster itt.

Even gerb aj and woody dont go that far.

You dont get to critique smarter posters arguments.
not close hey ?

i wonder when exactly ( year) you reach that conclusion of Lebron being much better than kobe

I am interested to know how far Lebron his over the top of Kobe as well, i am curious.


Anyway again,, i was speaking in the context of Barkley quote and the final arguments against Jordan about reaching more finals is more important than the actual results of it.
So quoting Kobe with a 5-2 record seemed adequate

You Just try to divert what i said and it is fine.
You style is easy since it is very hard to lose an arguments when you only criticize comments without putting forward your own arguments.
This way youre never being attacked and always on the offensive.
congratz
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rtd353
CLE equity goes down if they get Westbrook
really how so ?
isnt he a good scorer?
tho i know it would be impossible anyway it would happen but still.
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
really how so ?
isnt he a good scorer?
tho i know it would be impossible anyway it would happen but still.
He's a loser. A stat stuffing loser
LeBron = GOAT Appreciation Containment Thread, SABR42 & LuckyLloyd Co-MVP b/c of post #19140 Quote

      
m