Quote:
Originally Posted by onedollaratatime
I hear this all the time. Why shouldnt a rule like or similar to this exist? The NBA is a private company. Most companies have age/experience requirements for jobs throughout their companies. Why cant the NBA have the same?
I hear all the time that it is "un-constitutional" for the NBA to have the one and done rule. And to that I say 1) Its a private company and 2) Wheres the outrage for the NFL rule of 3 years?
I mean, I'm sure there are laws that could be challenged about the legality of the rule and how the NCAA and/or NBA are violating antitrust laws. The issue is "qualified" players are being locked out of an industry for a period of time with no alternatives. And I doubt overseas opportunities would have any impact on the legality of it.
In any other industry discrimination on age is illegal. Of course, there are de facto age restrictions, such as having a college degree, but someone extremely young and talented won't be turned away if they are of legal working age (say a person with a college degree at 18). The NBA has gone before congress to defend it's age discrimination, and it really can only fly for now probably because of how the employment is structured with contracts and lack of interest in continued court cases because of only a 1 year restriction.
Actually, here's a fairly old document of what I'm talking about.
https://scholarlycommons.law.case.ed...ntext=caselrev
Quote:
Originally Posted by onedollaratatime
To your second point of players going over seas. Several have tried it most notably Brandon Jennings and Emmanuel Mudiay. Those players play like 15 minutes a game over there and are 2nd and 3rd stringers. while on the front end they will receive more money than the players going to college, I think over the long haul they actually lose money due to the exposure they receive in the USA on the College basketball scene. This helps their draft stock, which helps their ability to be marketed and endorsement deals.
Or maybe they just suck. If the rule had existed when LeBron was coming out of HS, you think he would go overseas and just suck? Most of the players that go overseas are generally not that good. The elite ones know they can just go to college for a year, get exposure, and slay the competition. Like I said, if the rule was longer, I'm sure more players would go overseas, especially the top tier ones.