Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire

03-06-2021 , 09:12 AM
That was painful.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 09:24 AM
God, that was amazing.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 09:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
yeah i get that



unfamiliar with their soccer stuff but iirc the 538 model loses money each year when it paper trades and it's a running joke in the betting forum back when people posted there, not saying i can do better or anything



i think i mentioned this last year, but xg calculations are extremely subjective and have some massive holes in them, it's closest equivalent to US analytics would be defensive ratings in baseball, which everyone agrees are meaningless but nice to have as guidance



they don't account for the quality of a player, so a free kick taken by myself or by david beckham in his prime will will have the same xg so long as we kick it in the same general region



futhermore, by default, most off foot shots are dramatically reduced, to the point where it could have been .6 xg on the normal foot but .1 on the other, yet we know many players are excellent from both feet - this is a big reason why salah always outperforms his xg by significant margins



there's also a lot of "let's make the math work" done after the fact to normalize the data, this is why if you add up the individual player xG contributions, it does not equal the team xG



it's good stuff, i'm a big fan of it, it's a step in the right direction, but sadly the really good and actionable data is gathered by hd cameras who measure where everyone is on the field and that's all proprietary and none of the teams are letting that go public out of fear they may be ahead of the curve



i'd much rather just look at posession, corners and shots taken and find that more useful



i'm by no means an expert, just while doing my own modeling, i've found xg to not be all that useful if i was already accounting for the more traditional data, it was more a way smooth out the edges than anything else
I dunno how it's done in epl, but it's far and away absolutely crushed it in both men's and women's world cup for like 3 straight iirc.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 09:59 AM
Scream more Laca
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:03 AM
Quite the impressive appearance from Peters

Insta yellow card
Should've conceded a pen
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:05 AM
Handball rule perfectly fine
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:06 AM
Lucky to get away with that, but after the decisions we've had against Arsenal over the years, it's payback time.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:08 AM
And that was a bad miss.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:09 AM
pepe worth every penny for the lolz
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:09 AM
But not as bad as that one.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:11 AM
Lol Andrew Marriner
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:12 AM
Nowhere near a pen that one.

Tremendous block
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:13 AM
lol that was just pathetic

I was sitting here thinking that's going to be given.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:13 AM
Did Marriner just show him a yellow? Then he's off, I'm confused
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EnglishLad72
Did Marriner just show him a yellow? Then he's off, I'm confused
You are, aren't you. What on earth would he be showing a yellow for?
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:16 AM
He pulled out a red then a yellow, you tell me
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:17 AM
He showed him a red.

Then afterwards he showed him a yellow then a red and done like a no signal.

WTF?

I rewound it. He showed a red. Then showed a yellow then a red after the decision was cleared up.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EnglishLad72
He pulled out a red then a yellow, you tell me
Your answer lies here:

Quote:
Originally Posted by EnglishLad72
Lol Andrew Marriner
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:23 AM
I think he pulled out the red, motioned as if to rescind it, then just randomly showed a yellow again, lol these refs
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:23 AM
Mother****er
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:25 AM
Would love to read Xhakas contract, never gets dropped or subbed
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:28 AM
No team in the history of sports has lost as much ev in terms of wrong reffing decisions as arsenal just absolutely insane (the pieters one is NOT a handball/pen so not talking about that).
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:30 AM
i have no idea what a handball is anymore.


Last edited by kingofcool; 03-06-2021 at 10:40 AM.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:38 AM
VAR is absolute trash. It just gives the refs extra time to **** us.
English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote
03-06-2021 , 10:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kingofcool
i have no idea what a handball is anymore.

We all know that you're allowed to handle the ball in that particular penalty area.

English Football 2020-21 - now with 100% additional Yorkshire Quote

      
m