Quote:
Originally Posted by mw828
so don't buy pogba and pay a ridiculous price for lukaku (who is still at least somewhat limited) and get a LB that you rate more highly than ashley young and some other starters/good squad players. whose fault is that?
the argument is tantamount to "you can't blame mourinho for pep being a better manager in every way"
Ok then instead of spending the 140M they did this summer (not 200), they buy a competent back line instead (but then VVD just went for 75M) and they're still stuck with herrera, fellaini, lingaard, old mata and other mediocrity in the midfield. not going anywhere either
I don't think Pep is a genius manager (if you do then i'd be glad to hear what you thought 6 months ago when they were struggling to finish 4th despite spending the mot), I don't think Jose is a bad manager either, I do think the hate against him is exagerated and irrational a lot of the time because of strong bias against him (not questioning the reason for having a bias here) and as I said I think Man Utd are doing on par/better than they could hope for considering the talent they have in their squad. Pointing towards Mourinho for the lack of talent because is responsible of transfers (how much is he, who knows..?) is ok but you also have to take into consideration where he started from.
The comparison with City shouldn't exist, they had tons of talent already in the squad that would walk in United team (silva, kdb, aguero) and on top of that they added a bunch of >40M players at every position, have ridiculous depth and have had good luck with injuries