Quote:
Originally Posted by Ambush
Or can decision making (enough of it to be elite) be taught/learned to someone who seems to lack football IQ. Because if it can't someone like Memphis will never be elite regardless of his physical talent, maybe he's not such a talented player then.
Well, football IQ is certainly a component of talent.
Now, I think it obviously depends on the person/player, but up to a certain point I think you can definitely teach someone young better football IQ, either directly or they can learn indirectly by playing with better players. It's certainly likelier to be possible than it is to "teach" someone that is already past 20 better technique and physical attributes.
Put differently, I think that the marginal product of trying to teach football IQ is much higher for the average player (past 19-20 years old) than is the marginal product of teaching them to run faster or be better dribblers or shooters because I believe those factors have limited scope for improvement past a certain point that most reach around 20 or even before that.
So this was a very tedious way to say that Memphis has ingredients that most don't because they are not really a function of practice, that is what I mean by super talented.
It is impossible to know at this point whether or not he has the mental capability to learn better football IQ and become a
great player, but it's not really looking that good for him seeing as he is 21 and has already played at a pretty high level for some time now.
Football IQ, btw, probably does not have to coincide with intelligence. There are a lot of players with intelligent movement and decision-making that are probably dumber than a bucket of nails off the pitch.