This article makes for an interesting read imo:
The time when football fans were hated
I think it nails why some really hanker for the good old days:
Quote:
Anyone who watched football at that time will have their own stark memories. The stadiums were primitive. Men urinated against walls or into sinks at half-time due to the lack of toilets. What few women fans there were would have struggled to find a ladies toilet.
Fans stood packed together like sardines on the terraces, behind and sometimes under fences.
Quote:
The stadiums were ramshackle and noisy. Danger hung in the air along with the cigarette smoke. That was part of the thrill for many young men, Evans says. And it bred a camaraderie that is missing today.
Fans used to be seen as basically scum, and were treated as such by the police and authorities, now its very different and football crowds are treated pretty much like crowds at any other event.
Football is sanitized and expensive and commercialised, and maybe to much so, but its a pretty **** false dichotomy to say go back to the 80s.
Any alternative to the present offering would still have to be much more inclusive, tolerant and safe then football was in the 80s.