Quote:
Originally Posted by riverboatking
I think taking a knee might be better than kicking the FG in that spot.
Multiple people have said this and it's probably more wrong to have this opinion than it is to kick the FG. Obviously these numbers won't be entirely accurate due to being averages and not specific to the teams, but PFR calculator has up 3 at your own 1 with 5 minutes left as 76.7% (
http://pfref.com/tiny/KmsJb) and tie game at own 25 with 5 minutes left as 58.6% (
http://pfref.com/tiny/EFvlG), so taking a knee is giving up almost 20% win equity relative to kicking a field goal.
Down 4 at own 25 is 21.2% (
http://pfref.com/tiny/Goaud), which I think makes going for it is correct if conversion percent is ~32% which from 1 yard out it trivially would be.