Quote:
Originally Posted by CopTHIS
Kallis has an insane record on paper, especially when you add in his bowling. He's just too selfish and one-paced to be near the top of the list of all time greats, but you have to hand it to the guy - he's one hell of a player.
Erm, what? With all due respect, that's complete bollocks.
He'd make it into any right minded person's great list just on the strength of his batting alone; when you filter for a decent number of matches he's comfortably inside the top ten on the list of career averages - higher than such names as Hobbs, Tendulkar, Lara, Waugh, Dravid, Richards, Compton, Ponting, Hutton, Gavaskar, Miandad.......
Throw in well over 250 wickets, at low 30s, and 150+ catches, mainly from slips, and his only really serious contenders for the title of greatest all-rounder of all time are probably Garry Sobers and Imran Khan.
South Africa would be in pretty bad shape without his contributions this match, and the same could be said of dozens of matches over the last 15 years or so, where his batting has dug South Africa out of some deep holes. He's made his second hundred in this match,
with busted ribs. He's still got the guts for a fight when it comes to it.
Tests are not Twenty20 games. There are too many top order players players who come in, play a quick cameo innings of 45, rarely go on to give the team any sort of platform to build a big score and are of less value to their team than the stats suggest; Shane Watson comes irresistibly to mind here. The aim of the game isn't to throw the bat at everything and be out for an entertaining run-a-ball 45. The aim is to build a big team score, working in partnership with the other guy at the crease. Lest anyone forget, it's a five-day game. That's 450 overs. How many games actually last that long now? Not many, because most contemporary batsmen can't pace an innings like a Kallis, a Dravid or, dare I say it, a Boycott.....
And before anyone mentions Sehwag, he is a complete anomaly. Nobody else can repeately do what he does; many have tried, and all have failed.