I'm going to go ahead and quote some of A5's post over here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by aislephive
I don't think I've ever seen a PK so thoroughly dominated in one series, let alone one that was ranked 3rd in the league during the regular season. That the same 180 occured against TB last year makes me think there's a lot more to it than variance. For some reason against these highly skilled powerplays the Pens constantly overcommit and overpursue and that balls to the wall aggression ends up leaving all kinds of open passing lanes to exploit. Two years in a row our 'elite' PK has gotten dumped on in the playoffs and both times we failed to make any adjustments whatsoever. I just don't get it at all.
I think it's variance and ****ty goaltending but you're absolutely right that the Flyers ran the Pens' skaters ragged. I think you're overrating Tampa Bay last year, they weren't all that great on the power play. I think they just got hot at the right time, as they say.
Definitely with you on not getting it at all.
Quote:
The entire defense was trash except Letang, who wasn't up to his usual standards. Honestly I could do without seeing Martin, Orpik, and Michalek in a Pens uni ever again. Disgraceful playoff performance from them after what was a disappointing regular season. Complete turnaround from what I saw in 09-10 from those guys.
They weren't great this series, no doubt, but I strongly disagree with most of this. Martin was so shockingly bad in his few games to make me question my view of him being decent enough to play beside Letang. That doesn't take dazzling play just not ****ting the bed but he was incapable of getting close to that level. Still, I think you're overrating what second and third pairing guys typically bring to the table. I don't think we can get those results with Crosby missing so much time and Staal missing 20 games, not to mention last year, with the defensemen being close to what you describe. I think blue-line depth is actually a big strength on the team.
For some evidence of this, the Flyers' 5-on-5 shot rate in the series was 23.8 shots per 60 minutes. That's third lowest in the playoffs so far. In the regular season they were at 31.3. That's not the be all end all or anything, and I do think there is a shot-quality argument to be made here because there were some terrible turnovers, allowed breakaways and good ol' fashioned standing around leaving guys free to tuck in the awful rebounds Fleury was giving up but at the very least they did a pretty good job at suppressing shots. And yeah, that's all time and not just tied but the Pens were up for a lot of the series.
You know what makes defensemen look bad? Their goalie giving up a goal every five shots.