Quote:
Originally Posted by stealinpotatoes
What screwed up the OJ trial was that LA cops were provably racists and almost without doubt planting evidence and everybody who lived there knew it. Also OJ was nothing like Hernandez. Much more of an icon.
The big mistake in the OJ trial was the decision by Gil Garcetti, the DA, to appoint Marcia Clark as the lead prosecutor. For all her talents and abilities as Garcetti's top ADA, she was simply not cut out to argue that case in front of that jury. The snide comments she made - especially the caustic remarks directed toward F. Lee Bailey - did not sit well with jurors. As it became increasingly obvious that she was losing the case, her mocking derision became even more damaging to the prosecution. This, combined with the testimony/perjury of detective Mark Furhmann, virtually guaranteed OJ would walk.
Mr. Garcetti should have chosen a lead prosecutor who would have come across as being pained at having to try a role model - a defendant truly loved, admired and respected not just by members of the jury but by people all over the country. To neutralize OJ's defense team, the prosecutor would have showered Mr. Cochran and Mr. Bailey with praise as the truly great lawyers and advocates that they are - and how much he respects their skills and abilities. (Ms. Clark derisively comparing the size of a glove to a part of F. Lee Bailey's anatomy didn't score points with the jury.) To win over the jury, a good prosecutor would have empathized with the jurors and acknowledged how difficult their task was ... He (or she) would have made it clear that he understands how hard this is for members of the jury.
Ms. Clark went in to the trial thinking she already had OJ convicted and her "victory" would propel her into legal superstardom - she was on her way to becoming another Leslie Abrahamson or Gloria Allred. Instead, she blew the biggest case of her life. The real fault though is with Gil Garcetti - he simply should not have selected Ms. Clark to prosecute the case - although it's fairly easy to figure out why he did.