Quote:
Originally Posted by ligastar
It's true we don't know the state of Bile's mental health, but it's also true that it isn't fair to compare an athlete getting shook by pressure to a person struggling with depression and/or severe mental illness. I believe I incorrectly took this leap.
As part of my job, I support students who have mental or physical health issues. Some of them struggle so much with their mental health that they are unable to get out of bed for weeks at a time. Any athlete who has reached the top of their sport has de facto never suffered series mental health issues, or they would not have been able to achieve what they have.
That's not to say Biles or Osaka are in the midst of developing serious mental health issues. However, I suspect their issues are more akin to a student request to get a week's extension on a paper due to poor "mental health".
I certainly applaud them or talking openly and honestly about their issues, but I also think that looking from the outside in, it doesn't appear they are being advised that well.