Quote:
Originally Posted by newguyhere
That's a meh argument that could be used about any top 10-15 QB.
You know what the Phins were without Tua? the worst offense in the league.
does that mean he should be MVP? Of course not.
I actually don't even agree with this fwiw. The Phins are probably an 8 win caliber team with Tua, offense wasn't nearly as good last year even when he played.
Huntley was awful at first but he was signed off the street and thrown into starting right away.
If Huntley was signed in camp, think Phins probably only a few wins worse with him than Tua in 2024 on avg. With Hill fading, Miami offense just wasn't the same either way.
The Bills won 14 games, they would suck without Allen is my point. It is a subjective one and if he isn't gonna win MVP then so be it but just in terms of like the LeBron/Jokic who is the actual most valuable and propping their team up the most, I think it is him pretty easily.
I also feel pretty confident it would be a landslide if GMs had their pick to take 1 of the 2.