Quote:
Originally Posted by Carnivore
Maybe Goatani can add a 40/40 season to his resume.
40/40 is nice, but what's remarkable about Ohtani's season is that he's been a little unlucky with regards to batted balls. Typically when players are putting up career-high numbers in a month or so of baseball, they are usually running fairly hot wrt batted balls. Ohtani, on the other hand, is underperforming his expected stats by a decent amount:
Ohtani
BA: .365 (#1 in MLB), xBA: .373
SLG: .696 (#1 in MLB), xSLG: .756
wOBA: .480 (#1 in MLB), xwOBA: .505
While expected stats only go back to 2015, I think all three of these might be all-time high for a full season. The highest xwOBA ever recorded was .463 (you might have guessed, Aaron Judge in 2022). Ohtani is hitting the ball very much like Aaron Judge did in 2022 when he makes contact (xwOBACON of .604 vs .611 for Aaron Judge in 2022) while striking out at a substantially lower rate (18.1% vs 25.1% for 2022 Judge).
People talked about Ohtani potentially winning the batting title last season, but the reality was that he was never that close if you looked at expected stats, so he would've needed a lot of luck. This year, he's legitimately looking like a hitter that can hit .400 with some luck. He's striking out at a well below-average rate, while having all-time level batted ball profile.
Even while underperforming his expected stats, Ohtani's wRC+ and OPS+ are both higher than Judge's 2022 season. It's early, but he's off to an absurd start. We have an injured pitcher recovering from an elbow surgery, who was embroiled in a fake scandal for much of the season, currently on pace to have an all-time great hitting season. This is not normal.