Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018

01-30-2018 , 10:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dudd
So about that deadline...
Yeah, I thought it was safe haha. I'll reveal the Alex Smith answers I have already for fun, but will have to not award any points for the Alex Smith questions.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
01-30-2018 , 11:02 PM
Can't wait for someone to have accidentally left "Washington" as their answer to #1
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
01-30-2018 , 11:11 PM
Resubmits are obviously totally acceptable until SB.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
01-31-2018 , 01:11 AM
This Alex smiff news completely derailed my submissions. But, I do not think my overall score would’ve been affected much lol. I’ll keep it as is.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
01-31-2018 , 03:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dominic
I see the Chiefs expect to get a 2nd and a conditional 4th for Smiff.

Ahahahaha at any team that gives up those picks for him.

It’ll be the Bills.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
Resubmits are obviously totally acceptable until SB.
perfect - was just coming here to ask that
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-02-2018 , 08:58 PM
Reminder that there is less than 2 days left to enter and/or resubmit.

Reminder that questions 5 & 6 are no longer going to be counted so if you have not submitted, yet, you don't need to bother with those ones. Probably a good thing on #6 because I would have to extrapolate Fuller's chart value to come up with that #.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-03-2018 , 03:25 PM
IN!

May the lols begin
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-04-2018 , 05:18 PM
Yeah, this is going to be bad. Hour and a half left to get your answers in!
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-04-2018 , 05:19 PM
2 hours or so left to get in.

ETA: solid x-post
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 03:04 PM
I have 16 entries. Sadly, none from nath :/

Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
I need to subscribe to this so I remember to play.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
Can't wait for someone to have accidentally left "Washington" as their answer to #1
Will probably reveal answers as things become official, for now I'll get the early Alex Smith guesses out of the way.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 03:22 PM
So these were the choices of teams that Alex Smith would be on prior to the news leaking that he was heading to the WASHINGTON REDSKINS.

EntrantAlex Smith Team
wheatrichRavens
Perhaps ShimmyJaguars
NL SoldierBrowns
toedderChiefs
SuperUberBobChiefs
qblerChiefs
feel wrathCardinals
DuddChiefs
younguns87Browns
bigben241Cardinals
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 03:24 PM
A lot of you didn't do a great job of following directions regarding formatting of the pick...

(single # which represents the approximate pick if the picks traded were combined into 1 draft pick using the Chase Stuart Draft Value Chart)

EntrantAlex Smith Compensation
wheatrich50
Perhaps Shimmy120
NL Soldier90 & 120
toedderNone
SuperUberBobNone
qblerNone
feel wrathHigh second round
DuddNone
younguns8739
bigben2413rd Round
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 03:25 PM
So I had to do Guesstimate some conversions (well, had to is a strong word since this question doesn't count anyway)...

EntrantAlex Smith CompensationConverted
wheatrich5050
Perhaps Shimmy120120
NL Soldier90 & 12047.5
toedderNoneNone
SuperUberBobNoneNone
qblerNoneNone
feel wrathHigh second round36
DuddNoneNone
younguns873939
bigben2413rd Round80
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 03:32 PM
So the actual trade was the 77th pick + Kendall Fuller for Alex Smith. I didn't really anticipate players being included in the trade, & it doesn't count anyway, so I decided the best course of action would be to arbitrarily & capriciously assign Kendall Fuller a value in terms of what he would likely be worth in a trade on his own.

He was a 3rd round draft choice 2 years ago, has 2 very cheap years left on his contract, & was the #1 slot corner per PFF.

I think the 40th pick is a reasonable corollary for his worth. Per the Stuart chart, the 40th pick + the 77th pick is worth approximately the 14th pick.

Pursuant to the Stuart chart, though, I could have graded Fuller anywhere from the 106th pick or better & the result would be the same.

The most controversial thing about this, if this question, actually counted, is wtf pick does "high second round" equal? I would probably have gone top quadrant & made it 40th overall if this actually counted so as not to reward the inability to follow directions, but for the purposes of this exercise, 36 seems fine.

EntrantAlex Smith CompensationConverted"Correct"How Far Off?
feel wrathHigh second round361422
younguns8739391425
NL Soldier90 & 12047.51433.5
wheatrich50501436
bigben2413rd Round801466
Perhaps Shimmy12012014106
toedderNoneNone14Infinity
SuperUberBobNoneNone14Infinity
qblerNoneNone14Infinity
DuddNoneNone14Infinity
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 04:46 PM
How are you planning to do reveal? As news comes in? Or fixed chronological order ones training camps open or something?
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-05-2018 , 05:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by that_pope
How are you planning to do reveal? As news comes in? Or fixed chronological order ones training camps open or something?
As news comes in & is confirmed & such.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-06-2018 , 11:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
I have 16 entries. Sadly, none from nath :/
Yeah, I had a big thing this weekend and wasn't able to get around to it. There were a lot of questions!
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 04:14 PM
Will wait for some more confirmation, but it looks like the 1st shoe has dropped (Q3). If reports are accurate of 5/$137.5m deal, the correct answer is $27.5m.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 04:23 PM
Eh, seems official enough. 5/$137.5m/$74m in guarantees to stay with the 49ers.



 GuessDifferencePoints
NL Soldier$27,000,000 $500,00015
bazooka87$26,000,000 $1,500,00013.5
BillNye$26,000,000 $1,500,00013.5
Precept2$25,000,000 $2,500,00011.5
that_pope$25,000,000 $2,500,00011.5
SuperUberBob$24,000,000 $3,500,0009.5
feel wrath$24,000,000 $3,500,0009.5
Dudd$23,555,000 $3,945,0008
Perhaps Shimmy$23,000,000 $4,500,0007
bigben241$22,000,000 $5,500,0006
qbler$21,000,000 $6,500,0005
younguns87$18,300,000 $9,200,0004
TJ Eckleburg12$18,200,000 $9,300,0003
toedder$12,750,108 $14,749,8922
xander biscuits$2,000,000 $25,500,0001
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 05:21 PM
was 2 million a joke (trying to write 20m)?
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 05:40 PM
Decent start, and it being high bodes well for my other answers.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 06:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0
was 2 million a joke (trying to write 20m)?
I think xander doesn't follow NFL whatsoever, but doesn't like not playing games, so he submitted an entry, which is likely not going to turn out to be very accurate.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 06:36 PM
bink.

is it too late to resubmit on some other answers lol
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 07:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NLSoldier
bink.

is it too late to resubmit on some other answers lol
Not sure if you're looking for a serious answer or not, but yes haha.
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote
02-08-2018 , 07:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
I think xander doesn't follow NFL whatsoever, but doesn't like not playing games, so he submitted an entry, which is likely not going to turn out to be very accurate.
pretty much this

For a couple of the guys I looked up where their wives/girlfriends were from and assumed they would be henpecked into moving back there.

It's probably not how the NFL functions, but it gave me some answers
NFL QB Carousel 2018 Free Agency/Draft Guesstimania - entries due February 4, 2018 Quote

      
m