Quote:
Originally Posted by onedollaratatime
Why all the hate for Donovan Mitchell? I don’t get the sense he is currently overrated like Carmelo Anthony was his entire career. I get the sense Mitchell is seen as a top 15-20 player.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
I think seadood is saying it's substantially lower. Maybe top 40?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayTeeMe
Donovan is not a top 15-20 player. No way. The Jazz are good because they have a lot of good players that play super connected.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Heroball
Mitchell isn’t top 50. He’s the 4th best player on the Jazz.
Melo was way better at the same age.
Yeah when you say nobody thinks he's great and follow that up with top 15-20 it sort of hits my point. If you take the big advanced stats from last year here are his ranks, qualifying players >1000MP
RPM - 50th (4th on his team)
BPM - 94th (8th on his team)
PER - 96th
VORP - 48th (5th on his team)
WS/48 - 196th
The best he ranked was around 50th, and that is on a team that is absolutely tailor-made for him to do what he's good at. And the whole "not shying away from big moments" thing is a narrative that needs to go imo. PLENTY of players wouldn't shy from big moments if their team and coaching staff had no problem letting them jack a bunch of off-the-dribble 3's despite not being good at them.
I'd say he was about the 70th best player in the league last year, which is a far, far cry from the hype.
Then there are things I don't like about the shots he's getting. Like I've said before he's taking a ton of off-the-dribble 3's that teams are letting him have, and that has inflated his PPG. Teams go under for a reason, and him taking the shot that he's given and making them at poor-efficiency isn't something that should be celebrated imo.
I wonder how much worse or better Utah would have been had Devin Booker (younger), Jamal Murray(younger), or hell even Will Barton been put into that role and given the green light? My guess is Utah would be better (Booker), better (Murray), slightly worse (Barton) in that role... And before we talk about defense, we have to look at how different the roles are with Rudy and Favors as your back-line vs crippled Tyson Chandler and Jokic.
[edit] Also yeah DMitch >>>> Wiggins. I do wonder if Andrew would be much better with Quin's coaching though.