Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team 1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team

08-04-2012 , 12:37 PM
FWIW and maybe I am crazy but this game has little to nothing to do to the argument about the Dream Team. If anyone was questioning the level of dominance between the two teams then first lol and second clearly this would dispel any doubt in this argument.

I have seen tons of people of twitter blowing up about how this has to be the end of the debate, because clearly the world has gotten so much better at basketball since the 1992 team. To me this perhaps even strengthens the argument that 2012 could beat 1992's team, by using the claim that the game has changed and gotten much tougher especially worldwide since 1992 doesn't the strengthen the idea that bball players in 2012 on average are tougher/better than 1992?

Personally I don't really have a horse in the race in this debate, but I think there is something to be said for the argument that the game has changed so much since 1992 and the level of play is likely much higher in the NBA as well as Olympics.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 12:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andz
Liths had more rebounds(42:37) and more assists(21 : 13 LOL) , but they lost because of turnovers (23 ouch).If Americans play like this against Spain/Argentina or Russia they're gonna lose.

Spoiler:
ONE TIME PLEASE!!!!!
don't waste your one time, in 4 years you're going to want it back
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GimmeDat
oh my god BADUU's posts itt make me want to throw up
Yes, that usually happens when people are losing at debate. You are just another sheep in the line.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jmill
Oh man, the people coming out of the woodwork that were nowhere to be found after the 83 point win are awesome. The jimmies must have been seriously rustled after that Nigeria game. At least Matt is here rain or shine.
Yep coming out of the woodwork. And that is where you and the other fanboys of the 2012 team will go if the USA keeps playing like today.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:11 PM
win by 83 omg they're great, win by 5 omg dream team way ****ing better its not even close.


wish a mod would blow this thread up.

eta: fwiw i think coach k used some terrible lineups today.

Last edited by Scherer716; 08-04-2012 at 01:17 PM.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:13 PM
DT '92 lost a scrimmage against the likes of Bobby Hurley and other college players.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt R.
You can very easily quantify technological advancements in things like computers, jets, and the military. If someone wants me to explain how computers have advanced, I can very easily explain this by talking about processor technology and storage capacity because you can actually measure these things

However, when we do the exact same thing for modern athletes and try to quantify how much they've improved by using empirical evidence, in every instance where a sport is well developed the performances are relatively stable over the last 20 years. Training, nutrition, and strategy are secondary effects that can potentially LEAD TO better athletes and sports performance. They aren't directly measuring performance. When you directly measure performance in something like high jump, you see it's almost identical now compared to 20 years ago, and is actually slightly less. When you look at 100 meter times, you see it's only 2.8% less, and this record was set by a man that completely dominated even modern day sprinters. When you look at cross era players, you see that one of the best from a previous era can still win an MVP at almost 36 when he's old and competing against much younger players in the following era.

The mistake is that you are saying better knowledge of training, nutrition, and strategy can potentially lead to better athletes and better performance, therefore it does, and the difference is significant. Just because the potential is there does not mean it leads to way better improvement, and it doesn't mean you can somehow guess and quantify the magnitude of the improvement. When you do this you get absurd conclusions like the athletes in 2012 would completely dominate the athletes from 1992, conclusions that contradict every bit of available empirical evidence we have on the matter.

Basically, even though we do have these advances in training, nutrition, strategy, once we look at the evidence as to HOW MUCH it effects performance, we see that the effect (even though it probably exists) is extremely small relative to the training, nutrition, strategy we had in 1992. We can tell by looking at the performances, we don't have to speculate by guessing what better nutrition or slightly better weight training programs would do. The variance in how talented and how many elite players we have over a 2 decade time span completely overwhelms the effect that very slightly better training, nutrition, and strategy has. Just because this is true does not mean we don't think that these other effects are gradually improving.
LOL @ bringing this up again. 2.8% is huge in the 100 meters. There are 7 runners that have run faster in the 100 meters in the last 4 years, than Carl Lewis' world record that stood in 1992. If there were 7 basketball players now that were better than Michael Jordan, I think that would be plenty to make the game uncompetitive. Obviously, the 100m is a little fluky in that it's the event where modern track athletes have done the best, but the jumping events that have a 10 to 20 year old record are similarly fluky. There's a slow, steady progression in the sport as a whole, but variance will sometimes make it look like it's not progressing at all in some events while making it look much faster in others.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:17 PM
BTW, I guarantee you that if races weren't timed, and people just watched and gave their impressions, you'd get a bunch of nostalgia people out there saying "Usain Bolt's fast", but he's not as fast as Carl Lewis. Carl Lewis dominated, he's the GOAT." And then the people who chimed in on Bolt's side would get accused of "recency bias".
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BADUU
Yep coming out of the woodwork. And that is where you and the other fanboys of the 2012 team will go if the USA keeps playing like today.
Nah, I'll be right here regardless . You keep beating up on that strawman though pookie.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:18 PM
Lots to notice about todays game for the USA squad.

(1)To much 1 on 1
(2)Bad shooting from distance
(3)Poor Defense by multiple players

However, the main thing I saw.......is Kobe just looks OLD out there.

Good thing Lebron is around to bail them out at the end.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iggymcfly
BTW, I guarantee you that if races weren't timed, and people just watched and gave their impressions, you'd get a bunch of nostalgia people out there saying "Usain Bolt's fast", but he's not as fast as Carl Lewis. Carl Lewis dominated, he's the GOAT." And then the people who chimed in on Bolt's side would get accused of "recency bias".
Still on the track theme. Don't you have anything to contribute about basketball?
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:22 PM
Usain Bolt also beat the silver medalist by 2% in the 2008 Olympics. One man is reponsible for most of the difference. One man with no year round drug testing in his country. Tracks are a lot faster now too. PED use is way more widespread with 100 m sprinters and PED's are way more beneficial for straight line speed than dribbling and shooting.

How much have those other 7 sprinters with faster tracks and improved PED's beaten Carl Lewis by?
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jmill
Nah, I'll be right here regardless . You keep beating up on that strawman though pookie.
Pookie? are we long lost friends?
Hummm........instead of using the "strawman" term every other post, and throwing around loving euphemisms, maybe you could make a point on topic.

When you have something constructive to say about 2012 being better than the dream team, let us all know.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:27 PM
You act as though the improved PEDs aren't available to the top bball players as well.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt R.
Usain Bolt also beat the silver medalist by 2% in the 2008 Olympics. One man is reponsible for most of the difference. One man with no year round drug testing in his country. Tracks are a lot faster now too. PED use is way more widespread with 100 m sprinters and PED's are way more beneficial for straight line speed than dribbling and shooting.
See when you say things like this, it becomes really obvious that you're trolling. If only if it weren't for that one crazy outlier in Usain Bolt, only 6 runners in the current Olympics would be faster than Carl Lewis!


Quote:
How much have those other 7 sprinters with faster tracks and improved PED's beaten Carl Lewis by?
10 fastest men to ever run the 100 meters:

Rank Fastest time (s) Wind (m/s) Athlete Country Date Location
1 9.58 +0.9 Usain Bolt Jamaica 16 August 2009 Berlin
2 9.69 +2.0 Tyson Gay United States 20 September 2009 Shanghai
3 9.72 +0.2 Asafa Powell Jamaica 2 September 2008 Lausanne
4 9.75 +1.1 Yohan Blake Jamaica 29 June 2012 Kingston
5 9.78 +0.9 Nesta Carter Jamaica 29 August 2010 Rieti
6 9.79 +0.1 Maurice Greene United States 16 June 1999 Athens
7 9.80 +1.3 Steve Mullings Jamaica 4 June 2011 Eugene
(t) 9.80 +1.8 Justin Gatlin United States 24 June 2012 Eugene
9 9.84 +0.7 Donovan Bailey Canada 27 July 1996 Atlanta
(t) 9.84 +0.2 Bruny Surin Canada 22 August 1999 Seville

Carl Lewis' world record in 1992 was 9.86.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willd
You act as though the improved PEDs aren't available to the top bball players as well.
How many positive tests for PEDs have there been with NBA players over the past 20-30 years? Do you think PEDs help basketball players more or less than sprinters, who are simply running in a straight line?

Look at Kevin Durant, who has led the league in scoring each of the past 3 seasons. Can you tell me with a straight face this dude is on steroids?
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iggymcfly
See when you say things like this, it becomes really obvious that you're trolling. If only if it weren't for that one crazy outlier in Usain Bolt, only 6 runners in the current Olympics would be faster than Carl Lewis!
By a tiny fraction of Lewis' time 20 years ago. The magnitude is relevant, so I'm not sure what you're talking about or why you think I'm trolling.



Quote:
10 fastest men to ever run the 100 meters:

Rank Fastest time (s) Wind (m/s) Athlete Country Date Location
1 9.58 +0.9 Usain Bolt Jamaica 16 August 2009 Berlin
2 9.69 +2.0 Tyson Gay United States 20 September 2009 Shanghai
3 9.72 +0.2 Asafa Powell Jamaica 2 September 2008 Lausanne
4 9.75 +1.1 Yohan Blake Jamaica 29 June 2012 Kingston
5 9.78 +0.9 Nesta Carter Jamaica 29 August 2010 Rieti
6 9.79 +0.1 Maurice Greene United States 16 June 1999 Athens
7 9.80 +1.3 Steve Mullings Jamaica 4 June 2011 Eugene
(t) 9.80 +1.8 Justin Gatlin United States 24 June 2012 Eugene
9 9.84 +0.7 Donovan Bailey Canada 27 July 1996 Atlanta
(t) 9.84 +0.2 Bruny Surin Canada 22 August 1999 Seville

Carl Lewis' world record in 1992 was 9.86.
Thanks. Looks like Carl Lewis was within a fraction of a percent of all but 4 of those times, 20 years ago.

How much would you attribute to faster tracks? How about better PEDs and better strategies for beating drug tests?
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BADUU
When you have something constructive to say about 2012 being better than the dream team, let us all know.
I don't really need to, as I haven't been arguing that one side is clearly that much better than the other. I've been arguing it's close either way. You're the one that seems to have a clear bias towards one side.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 01:46 PM
Also, Carl Lewis competed in the long jump and was the best in the world. This took away his training time for the sprints, and competing in the long jump took away some of his energy when actually running the races. Usain Bolt doesn't compete in nor train for this completely different event, and this gives him more time/energy to improve his sprint times.

None of the other sprinters you mentioned compete in jumping events either.

How much do you think this effected Carl Lewis's times? What if we combine this factor with the slower tracks and not having access to the more advanced PEDs?

Would this affect his time more than a fraction of a %? I'd say almost certainly.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 02:27 PM
Have tracks really gotten faster since 1992? I haven't heard anything about this. If you could link to an article or something, that would be great. I Googled and came up with nothing.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 02:42 PM
This explains it a little bit:

http://coachjoeenglish.wordpress.com...aster-or-slow/

I remember in the lead up to the Beijing Olympics people talking about how the track was constructed and how fast it was for sprinters with the more advanced surface. I'll have to look harder for more specific stuff -- I keep getting junk with the google terms I'm using.

Edit -- derp I probably should have tried "beijing track surface":

http://www.designnews.com/document.a...Layout=article
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 03:13 PM
As for the other major jumping event, this jump:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DEt_Xgg8dzc

Would have been good for gold in the 2008 Olympics. It would have beaten the 2008 gold medalist's jump by almost 15%.

(For those that don't click on the link, this jump took place 44 years ago.)
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 04:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by brandoncla
Cliffs: 2012 team sets record against Nigeria. Now 2012 team is supposively > DT.
Cliffs: Lithuania plays 12' team close.... '12ers now backing down their hard line stance. 1 game at a time.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 04:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0
What does the Karl Malone MVP mean. It means Karl, one of the players who lasted a really long time in the NBA, could dominate without athleticism, but most players who dominate in NBA do. Please tell me what the **** you are trying to prove with the Karl Malone MVP. Literally, it's such a weak and awful point I just don't get it.
we can stop beating the 'lolmvp' horse; it's already been converted to glue. so let's just change it to MVP-candidate or -level. to me, the point is that Malone must have some of those non-measureables that imo would factor into a game between the 2 best basketball teams ever assembled. And given how old he was, he must have a lot of them. now, you can argue he didn't have them when he was younger, but... let's not.

-------------------------

obviously, "omg they won by 80" vs "omg they won by 5" is a red herring. if anything, it might illustrate how dependent the 12ers are on their 3-point shooting tactical advantage. durant's average on defense afaik, but LOL melo/love.

I still think the 12ers' deficiencies >> the DTers' deficiencies. And when you look at both sides of the coin, DT>12.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote
08-04-2012 , 04:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by brandoncla
Cliffs: Lithuania plays 12' team close.... 92ers rush to thread to point out DT>>>2012 team. 1 game at a time.
Flip side to that coin.
1992 USA Dream Team vs. 2012 USA Men's Bball Team Quote

      
m