I found a hand where there is a discrepancy in winnings through both PT3 and HEM. It is a hand where I won $5.25 but PT3 says I won only $3.25 and HEM says I lost $2.00.

PT3 Hand History:

Full Tilt Poker Game #21625198203: Table Fallbrook (6 max) - $1/$2 - Limit Hold'em - 23:53:07 ET - 2010/06/14
Seat 1: Hero ($75)
Seat 2: mrtwistertx ($41)
Seat 3: BeMySushi ($18.50)
Seat 4: Chodirt-eh ($54.25)
Seat 5: KahueRozzi ($29)
Hero posts the small blind of $0.50
mrtwistertx posts the big blind of $1
The button is in seat #5
*** HOLE CARDS ***
Dealt to Hero [Kd Ah]
mrtwistertx: nh
BeMySushi folds
Chodirt-eh folds
Chodirt-eh stands up
KahueRozzi calls $1
Hero raises to $2
mrtwistertx calls $1
KahueRozzi calls $1
*** FLOP *** [6s 4d Jh]
Hero bets $1
mrtwistertx folds
KahueRozzi folds
Uncalled bet of $1 returned to Hero
*** SUMMARY ***
Total pot $6 | Rake $0.25
Board: [6s 4d Jh]
Seat 1: Hero (small blind) collected ($5.75), mucked
Seat 2: mrtwistertx (big blind) folded on the Flop
Seat 3: BeMySushi didn't bet (folded)
Seat 4: Chodirt-eh didn't bet (folded)
Seat 5: KahueRozzi (button) folded on the Flop

While the HH is accurate, the software window shows I only won $3.75.

HEM Hand History:

***** Hand History for Game 21625198203 ***** (Full Tilt)
$1.00/$2.00 Limit Texas Hold'em - Monday, June 14, 11:53:07 ET 2010
Table Fallbrook (6 max) (Real Money)
Seat 5 is the button
Seat 1: Hero ( $75.00 USD )
Seat 2: mrtwistertx ( $41.00 USD )
Seat 3: BeMySushi ( $18.50 USD )
Seat 4: Chodirt-eh ( $54.25 USD )
Seat 5: KahueRozzi ( $29.00 USD )
Hero posts small blind [$0.50 USD].
mrtwistertx posts big blind [$1.00 USD].
** Dealing down cards **
Dealt to Hero [ Kd Ah ]
BeMySushi folds
Chodirt-eh folds
KahueRozzi calls [$1.00 USD]
Hero raises [$1.50 USD] - (I raised $2)
mrtwistertx calls [$1.00 USD]
KahueRozzi calls [$1.00 USD]
** Dealing Flop ** [ 6s, 4d, Jh ]
Hero bets [$1.00 USD]
mrtwistertx folds
KahueRozzi folds
Hero wins $1.00 USD


The hand history in HEM is inaccurate. BUT the hand replayer in both HEM and PT3 are accurate. I'm stumped.

I have posted on both software websites and have yet to recieve a response. Anyone else come across this?

The pot that was given to you was $5.75, but $2 of that already belonged to you so you really only won $3.75.

Importing this into PT3 shows you winning $3.75, not $3.25, and it is accurate.

This is a quote from the programmer:

This is already fixed and tested in our internal build. You will be able to purge the hand and reimport it after our next public release.

Jeez . . .

$3.25 is a typo.

I had noticed a discrepancy in winnings between HEM and PT3. Maybe in being hyper-scrutinizing, I overlooked the obvious. And maybe missing the winnings line made it easier to do, but you for pointing it out.

FYI to anyone curious or noticing the same thing, HEM's total is wrong and was told in the site's forum that it is a known bug and that it will be fixed in the next release. So PT3 looks accurate and HEM doesn't for the time being.