@sir_Achil,
I'm unaware if this is already pointed out (as I only read your initial post), but you really messed up on the emails in my opinion.
You mentioned that you're really dedicated to becoming a poker pro and that you would basically want to do it for a living.
Now I'm already not convinced that you could make a living out of it; 14K profit is nice, but is easily doable for any poker player with an edge over 9K games.
This aside, if you really want this as badly as you say you do, why not sent an email that would be application-material?
You should've written this email carefully and assure that you didn't sent it after all spelling and grammar mistakes were corrected.
Why didn't you just go with a more professional approach?
- Proper introduction
- Well written mid-text
- Attached old emails with your communication history with PokerStars, in which you immediately showed regret and apologized
- No grammatical/spelling errors
- Proper ending, sending your regards and signed by your own first and last name instead of your poker nick's
Also even mentioning you should be awarded your account back, because you could've just used accounts of relatives to keep playing on the network, is beyond foolish.
The fact that you're saying this probably already makes them wonder that this seriously crossed your mind and that you might even have played on other accounts.
I sure as hell wouldn't have written this if it didn't cross my mind as an option to start playing again.
By saying other stuff like: "you never gave me a chance to proof I can be a normal poker player", you're basically accusing them of this, while you're not even in the position to do so.
Should've just broken contact after your initial apology and sent a gentle, friendly email three years later without any finger pointing.
I don't understand why you attached all your story's about your FTP winnings either. How should your accomplishments in online poker be factored into their decision making?
Hey the guy that once colluded on our poker site has suddenly made a lot of money on some other poker site, let's take him back!
That's not how it works obviously, if anything I'd say it actually doesn't favor you at all saying that.
I don't know to what extend you colluded, but I think Stars made the right decision, on both declining to unfreeze your account and to restrict your from playing on FTP as well.
About that...
SharkScope shows you have been playing in April of 2013. How do you explain that? You posted this around January 2013, so you shouldn't be allowed to play, as you mentioned.
Do explain...