Quote:
Originally Posted by miajag
Marching and writing to your Congressman is nice and all, but those things do not disrupt the lives of the comfortable, which is what needs to be happening until this is fixed. And by "fixed" I don't mean the inevitable bull**** measure Congress passes that allows parents to stay in the cages with their kids, I mean the abolition of ICE and the prosecution of those in charge of it.
Decided to come out of a 6 month hibernation to note: this is all well and good. And it should be cheered on.
But it's fundamentally limited. As you correctly note, *most* of this energy will dissipate once the GOP and Democrats join arm-in-arm to 'reunite families' -- that is, our political system is only equipped, at best, to rectify the most ghoulish, inhumane and currently visible aspect of America's dog**** immigration policies.
It may be that our devolution into barbarism is so complete that we can't even achieve that. But we might. And if we do, the reunification will surly be far too late, as the harms done are permnent. They may be mostly fictional as it's likely ICE and the Trump Admin haven't a ****ing clue nor much cared what happened to any of the families they tore apart. And the reunification may very well be only behind bars. It would be extremely fitting for our times if the bipartisan solution is cheer ourselves for 'reuniting families' while keeping them in concentration camps and Tender Age Tents.
Perhaps if America's best propagandists are assigned to find a workable solution to achieve elite consensus between the insane right-wingers and centrists who hold all of the power in this country, the victims of our crimes will get a half-hearted apology, but surely they will get a warning not to come back and do tell their friends.
And soon enough, we'll be back to the bipartisan consensus, which is roughly this:
Joe ****ing Manchin can't even defend the inalienable human rights of children without grovelling about how we need military toys to harass migrants.
Like all things, Trump is one part startling acceleration and one part apogee of processes now in motion for 40 years: taking migration from a largely civil matter to a mostly criminal one. Militarizing the border. Ratcheting up the machinery of deporation for non-violent immigrants. But he is not a pivot. He's not unique. He's just the next evolutionary step of long-gestating forces. Give the right-wing credit: in their moments of recent public relations chaos, they will sometimes let their guard down and let the veil slip, and plead with the public to note their enforcement mechanisms are only slightly more vicious than Obama's and Clinton's. This is of course only temporary, and done with great pains, as they surely are aware that for their audience of ferocious racists, they are giving the Democrats a huge victory. Which is why they will reflexively turn back to their fantasies that actually Democrats are Crime Loving feckless weakling race-traitors who let the immigrants in because Deep State Soros electioneering or whatever the ****.
But the underlying truth that Trumpkins and the rest of the GOP let slip is critical: callous treatment of immigrants as subhuman is the bipartisan consensus among the elite for generations now. The debate is the matter of degree.
America is being set into this posture by literally tens of millions of people with absolute bloodlust on their hearts and eliminationist ideals in their minds. They have listened to 40 years of rhetoric that cast immigrants as welfare cheats, violent criminals, or vermin bent on infestation and invasion, depending on how deep into the Intellectual Dark Web they go. Their heros are Minutemen Militia and other violent posses promising to harass migrants on the border, gestapo agents like Joe Arapaio, and President Trump, who spent the Presidential campaign promising a savage and punishing immigration policy and is now delivering. This could not be any clearer. Anyone feigning surprise is the worst sort of bad faith artist; denying the obvious perhaps to shield their own complicity in America's downfall into fascism.
Taking to the streets might get enough Chamber of Commerces to compel the billionaire class into threatening the GOP to withhold their donations and maybe get some mealy-mouthed commitments to end separation. But that's about the best we can hope for in the short-term. I strained to point out that the path to Baby Immigrant Prisons was predictable and tolerated, and largely elite consensus, if not in specifics then in its structural elements. We are confronted with a deep underlying systemic problem -- a population absolutely primed and ready to wage revanchist violence against migrants and racial minorities -- an idea that has been flattered by both major political parties and the machinery of political rhetoric that goes with it.
Systemic problems require systemic solutions. We need an actual, meaningful
political movement to change the underlying public sentiments. As the median political opinion in America seems to be something like immigrant parents should be able to keep their kids by their side as they dodge Blackhawk helicopters and drones haunting their steps to keep them out of a country that absolutely does not welcome them ... this seems formidable.
The work ahead is to create a more permanent, durable political will around the principle that migrants are indeed fully human. Predicting the long term future is hard but I think we are headed for worse even if this particular policy changes. Until the left can present a coherent, unified refutation of the idea that enforcement of immigration law is the highest priority and debasement of migrants as starting point, it's hard to be hopeful.
tl;dr summary: Joe Manchin is ****ing garbage and symbolic of why we're absolutely ****ed