Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
No, he has the support of Labour Party members, who are less than 1% of the population and a very weird less-than-1% at that. Most of the members have only joined since 2015. It is not a coincidence that the EDL and UKIP have collapsed in that time: they've all joined Labour. So have former members of the International Socialists, Militant, the Socialist Workers' Party, Respect and other red-fascist groups. Labour is now an overtly fascist party, hence the rather rabid attacks on Jewish and anti-fascist Labour MPs, which Corbyn is doing nothing to discourage or punish. (Ken Loach, for instance, is still a party member. He should have been expelled last autumn when he engaged in Holocaust denial in a BBC interview, and he should never have been admitted in the first place because as recently as 2015 he was campaigning against Labour. But Corbyn actually likes Loach's fascist schtick.)
Among voters at large, Corbyn's approval rating is terrible, well below -20, while the ineffectual Theresa May's is around -5. And about 75% of Labour voters are opposed to Brexit, whereas Corbyn is a fanatical, swivel-eyed, diehard Brexitard.
This is painful stuff. One would think not worth responding to but this kind of nonsense is getting a surprising amount of traction in the press.
'EDL and UKIP have all joined Labour'. If you truly believe this you have no concept of what any of these groupings are, still less a citation to back it up.
The SWP (the IS ceased to exist in 1977) had/has less than 5000 members (probably much less) and is by far the biggest far left organisation. Exact membership figures are impossible to come by, let's say a very generous 10 000 total from Respect, SWP, Socialist Party (millitant which ceased to exist circa 1990) + assorted fringe groups (not all of whom have joined Labour) you are talking less than 10 000. This is out of an increased membership from 150 000 to around 600 000. There were 400 000 members in 1997, it is reasonable to assume many of these returned. Before the surge, Corbyn won 150 CLP nominations, with Burnham and Cooper around 110 each. Kendall less than 20. The support for Corbyn was consistent across all groups of members.
In any case, to describe mostly dedicated decent people as 'red-fascists' is meaningless and insulting.
'Labour is now an overtly fascist party'. Again you have no understanding of what the term fascist means.
To say Ken Loach engaged in holocaust denial is an offensive lie. Loach in a letter to the Guardian:
You recently published an attack on me and others by Jonathan Freedland (theguardian.com, 27 September) suggesting we were in part responsible for Labour’s “dark place”. In particular, it was alleged that I gave “spurious legitimacy” to Holocaust denial. Can I at least make one thing clear? In a BBC interview, where speech overlapped, my words have been twisted to suggest that I think it is acceptable to question the reality of the Holocaust. I do not. The Holocaust is as real a historical event as the second world war itself and not to be challenged. In Primo Levi’s words: “Those who deny Auschwitz would be ready to remake it.” The terrible pictures I first saw as a nine-year-old are ingrained on my memory, as they are for all my generation. Like readers of this paper, I know the history of Holocaust denial, its place in far right politics and the role of people like David Irving. To imply that I would have anything in common with them is contemptible. There are many, Jews and non-Jews alike, who challenge Freedland’s judgment on the allegations of antisemitism. The Jewish Socialists’ Group wrote “accusations of antisemitism are being weaponised to attack the Jeremy Corbyn-led Labour Party”. My full response is available online at the website of Jewish Voice for Labour
https://www.theguardian.com/world/20...locaust-denial
Re Corbyn approval etc, you will see after 3rd May the people will have spoken. Only a matter of time before Jeremy Corbyn is elected Prime Minister of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I think that thought is probably more painful for you than it is joyous for me.
Last edited by tomj; 04-23-2018 at 09:23 PM.