Quote:
Originally Posted by einbert
It's becoming increasingly clear that to many Americans, the simple fact of our military and economic dominance is what makes us great. It has nothing to do with our freedoms, our democracy (ha), the integrity of our judicial systems or our elections or even having great and wise leaders. It's simply being America, being USA #1.
Well in fairness, America's dominant position in the global order was a slow process that built primarily from the 1870s to the 1950s; during much of the time America wasn't quite as ideal as our best narratives might portend.
This is one of those areas where I do think liberals do themselves a disservice lambasting the right for their failure to acknowledge America is Already Great, etc., even if we all agree the right wants to backslide into autocracy and minority-rule. The opposite of "the right wing has terrible impulses" is not that the status quo is great or that we've always embodied the opposite of what right-wingers want.
I guess it's minor and fit for another thread but I'll use it as a jumping off point here that liberals should be working to disarm people of their fear of outsiders (hard, I know) rather than speaking to altruism and high-ideals and abstractions about the justice system and freedom that are in many ways just as fictional as the narratives the right-wing foists on people. We don't always have a justice system that operates with integrity, our democracy is problematic, our freedoms aren't perpetual and enduring for everyone. So there's a lot of fictions bundled into the counter-narrative, so to speak. I'm not going to give the right any credit here but you do have to appreciate liberals find themselves looking ham-handed when on the one hand we say, well we need Democrats in office to bring a more just social order, why look at the impoverishment and the problems in the justice system with how it treats black people and how women are treated, and how unfair it is to the poor, then beat up the right for failing to recognize our inherent goodness. That's where we might rightfully get seen as needlessly sanctimonious to observers.
Last edited by DVaut1; 02-27-2017 at 02:18 PM.