Quote:
Originally Posted by Melkerson
... under the circumstances, she was required to identify herself (i.e., tell them who she was), but she doesn't actually have to *show* ID...
No. You don't ever have to identify yourself at all... ever. In fact, this is a strategy to fight back against mass arrests during direct actions. They have to arraign you within 72 hours, and if a critical mass refuses to cooperate with the process they'll let everyone go. The key is to not carry ID, and when asked to identify yourself to invoke your right to refuse to speak, and insist on your right to a lawyer. Don't lie about your identity, because that's a separate crime that they will be able to screw you with.
Of course, as a practical matter outside of activism, if you don't identify yourself expect to go to jail.