Quote:
Originally Posted by will1530
Except it's not clear that Zimmerman instigated any sort of violence.
This is where me and the other side seem to disagree. I think of Zimmerman as a general menace. He's a righteous criminal vigilante who is trying to do something that is not his job. The self defense crowd wants to look only at who threw the first punch. Which I don't think we will ever know since the witness only knows who was on top. Or more, I am not sure I trust this leak of the witness' account. I don't really trust any of the people in this story. I don't know who the witness is at all and Zimmerman is a complete loon.
Based on the facts that we know absolutely for sure I think of attempt of Zimmerman to drive down the street and follow with the intent to get out of his car and engage Martin with a gun on him he became the aggressor in the situation. I think that Martin was acting in self defense. If a fight ensued and Martin got the upper it does not show that Zimmerman was ever seriously injured. I don't think there was a reason for Zimmerman to be driving around with a gun looking to engage black kids. That was his plan. When he executed his plan **** got out of hand and he killed someone. Distractions about who was on top at what time is not relevant to the fact that Zimmerman approached Martin from his vehicle with a gun, for no reason, and got out of his car and eventually killed him. The grey area in between is speculation at best.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DblBarrelJ
So if I punch you in the nose you believe you have the right to shoot me?
Clearly you do because you believe that if I punch you and you draw your gun and I see you drawing yours and shoot you, I'm wrong.
If you come up out of the blue and punch me in the nose? You're going to have to expand slightly on this hypothetical. I would probable have the right to shoot you.
Yes. In your last part I think you do not have the right to shoot me if you punch me and I grab my gun. You deserve to punished at the very least. Arrested for violating the law. If there is no law that covers punching me in the face then that's pretty ****ed.