Quote:
Originally Posted by jayhawks
Yeah, what he said is bull****. I disagree about it being a bungled raid, though. And not because they're now saying that there wasn't much intelligence gathered. It's because the plan usually never goes as planned and it can go sideways fast. I'm sure they didn't expect the woman and teenagers to pick up weapons, but I can't be sure. Once a severe gunfight like that begins, it's all about survival. It's sad that the U.S. lost an elite operator, another SEAL got his jaw shot off, and civilians died. They know what they signed up for.
Yeah, we need to be careful with the "bungled raid" hot take. I get that Trump blaming the generals is ****ing awful, but let's remember that bungled raids are a natural consequence of warfare. Jimmy Carter sent special forces in to free the Iranian hostages and they "bungled it". Hell, George Washington lost battles; a whole bunch of them. The bin Laden raid might have been a bungled raid if the helicopter pilot hadn't managed to pull off a gentle crash landing. The essential difference is not that Carter or Washington led bungled operations, it's that they understood that the buck stops with the Commander in Chief.