Quote:
Originally Posted by cuserounder
I'd imagine your history makes it less likely you'd elect someone like Trump, though, right? (I know little about current German politics beyond Merkel, if I'm being honest.)
To some extent, the majority of a population is only going to know their own experiences and to some degree their parents/grandparents experiences. I think a huge percentage of the American electorate thought, and still thinks, that our democratic republic is indestructible, whereas a lot of people in Europe understand that's not the case due to being only a couple generations removed from a wave of fascism.
So basically, way too many people in the US laughed off Trump's rhetoric, and while there has been a hard-right movement in some European countries with varying degrees of success, I feel like it's meeting more resistance - especially in countries that fell victim to fascism within the last 80 years... Are my feelings/assumptions on this correct?
I think there are lots of European countries where politicians with Trump-like rhetoric are polling in the 20-30% range or even higher. Le Pen in France, Wilders in the Netherlands, Hofer and the FPÖ in Austria and in Poland and Hungary this is even true for the governments. Although I have to admit the rhetoric is similar, but they mostly seem far less buffoonish (except for Wilders, maybe).
I don't think Germany is such a special case because of it's history. If we had had the refugee crisis fifteen years ago, I think things would have been much different here, especially concerning the ruling party CDU, but the social democrats would also have been much more torn on this issue, I guess. In case anyonw around here is from Germany and old enough to remember politicians like Roland Koch, Friedrich Merz and even Jürgen Rüttgers, a government run by these guys would make for a very different reaction to the refugee crisis and if anyone remembers the "Kinder statt Inder"-campaign of 2000 you also know that the population in Germany isn't immune to xenophobia.
I think what does make Germany different is a range of factors. A conservative party lead by Merkel, reacting the way she did in the refugee crisis, the history of Nazi-Germany, positive experiences with foreigners like the "guest worker program" from the 60s or students doing semesters abroad.
Still Germany is not immune to right-wing tendencies.