Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
Not sure how much of this is just me being precious but I am starting to reconsider the effect of the sarcastic repetition of right wing talking points. I engage in it as much as anyone (if not more) but in the light of just how dumb most people have proved themselves to be what is the chance that there are large amounts of people missing the sarcasm and thinking "even liberals are talking about benghazi it must be serious business". Obviously blaming snarky libs for trump is not something I'm particularly fond of but in the age of fake news something as comparatively subtle as the above exchange might genuinely be muddying the waters for large groups of dumb people.
The go to for internet liberals does seem to be repeating republican talking points but in a sarcastic manner. I worry the sarcasm is disregarded and the fake news is unintentionally reinforced. It's going to be a tough habit to break especially for me but I think I'm personally going to try and tone it down. The benefit of me feeling superior (while important) doesn't outweigh even the small possibility that I'm causing damage to the progressive cause.
very well said.
I thought exactly the same after watching this video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqrahBJkKAs&t=1s
avout space exploration.
the girl used extrem sarcasm and this has to be one of the worst talks ever as she destroyed her own intention by using that sarcasm.
end result being tons of people turning of the video after 2mins and saying shes dumb and taking what she said at 1st level.
Then even stupider people coming in comment saying
that sarcasm was obvious and video is adressed to intelligent people.
and here is the major flaw:
the people that got the sarcasm were already the convinced people.
only thing the fancy sarcasm did was to make the actual target(the average joe that you are trying to educate) flee and turn off the video.
Quote:
The benefit of me feeling superior (while important) doesn't outweigh even the small possibility that I'm causing damage to the progressive cause.
thats the feeling of the people praising the sarcasm use,they are so smart they dont see they are the one missing the point.
tldr:you cannot assume you will be understood ,and looking how trump communicates like a 5 year old, opposition should adjust as I dont see anyone pro trump criticizing that language style,hence it works for them (keep the fancy stuff for your diaries)