Quote:
Originally Posted by simplicitus
Can someone write a Twitter essay on the incoherence of the whole Western way of life under threat from a few Muslim fundamentalists who entirely depend on a resource that will have less value in 20 years?
It seems to me that the complaint is actually with the continued expansion of "western values" as embodied in ideas like science, reason, natural rights, and democracy to brown and black people, including in the US. That is, the moran who wrote the speech for the puppet to give is concerned with the expansion of western values in a manner analogous to those who resisted the notion that "all men are created equal" should be read to mean blacks and women.
Are the ideas of some dude hiding in a cave somewhere so he don't get blown up an actual threat to the future of western civilization? (Will the white women lose interest in us if blacks can own land? Will same sex marrige make me go gay?) If so, then we best reexamine the strength of enlightenment ideals, because they must be pretty damn weak.
And is the idea actually that only white people can appreciate the superiority of reason as a guide to thought and conduct and are thus capable of democracy? Because it seems to me that if the rest of the cannot see the virtue of 'western values', it is because they will inevitably fail to appreciate the allure of science, pluralism, reason, tolerance, and free expression and are thus incapable of existing in democratic societies. Now, I grant it often takes a generation or two for such ideas to take hold, and there are powerful forces that seek to oppose them, but they are the most virulent memes (pace Dawkins) that have ever existed, and with the ever growning speed and means of information dissemination, it was pretty much game over 100 years ago, maybe 200 years ago. The table has already been set, we're just in the mop up phase.