Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
Maybe a little dramatic, but it's pretty f-ing important. The things about Trump that offend me the most are his assaults on the institutions and processes (open press, tolerance for dissent, independent courts, free elections, etc.) that are essential to decency and fairness in a free democratic society.
One of the things that we should be concerned about the very valid (imo) view of commentators and academics is that democracy and transparency are backsliding in many places. There's obvious examples like Russia, like Turkey, like the US. But even in Western Europe and South Korea, far-right populist parties have been ascendant or made some gains (like Brexit). And authoritarianism and illiberal tactics like repression of the press Trump is symbolic of processes happening everywhere. Including the US, even pre-Trump, it's not like the press was thriving and vibrant. Like, we're not even 15 years removed from the US pre-emptively invading a country based on lies, destroying the region, installing a torture regime. Much of which the press abetted. It's not like transparency was ascendant and universally respected as a norm. We paid lip service to it, but critics have pointed out how the US has been backsliding in those areas for some time. The same with elections; lots of events have been percolating and undermining fairness and voter participation that have been long in gestation and pre-date Trump.
As contemporaries living through it, it's likely we miss the bigger picture sometimes. I suspect historians long from now may see this period as an unwinding of the norms we cherish -- but dating back quite far from today. Perhaps decades. Which isn't to say we can't rally and restore them. But it's way more than Trump. For me, personally, right now -- I think Trump is a manifestation of stuff I long-recognized -- namely that huge amounts of people really actually despise the norms we cherish, or at the very least place no value on -- but assumed we had control of. Assumed there was a deeper consensus. That's what Trump is to me: he broke the false consensus we enjoyed.
In the end, as you say, Trump expresses many of the worst attributes of a potential future in worrying ways. But I maintain he is still symbolic of changes long-brewing, of changes we see happening elsewhere in the world. Changes we've seen developing here in the US for a long time if we employ even light scrutiny. That speaks to how illiberal tendencies have emerged, what's behind them, and how to solve it: Trump is a follower, not a leader. He's seizing on collective bad impulses, on groundwork being laid for a long time. Trump is just a very crude implementation of long-simmering tendencies and trends.
Last edited by DVaut1; 07-05-2017 at 01:11 PM.