Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
The rub, as we can all rightly guess, is that responding to a pollster indicating your desire to impeach Trump costs ~nothing but for a huge majority of people, week long street protests would get them fired or result in a week of lost income, or have other huge life consequences or challenges.
A better, more durable politics should involve organizing for the long term. Perhaps we can say times are so desperate we all need to be in the streets for a week, but that's a very reactive stance. One of the tenants of say community organizing is that the goal is to seek power, not just protest. What the left needs to rebuild is what trade unions built in the early 20th century; through organization and coordination, a small number of professionals and leaders were able to be hugely influential and powerful and enact change without having to disrupt or make huge demands on the individual members of the bodies. That the right set about on a huge, generations long project to destroy and dismantle unions is no accident. The unions did a lot for normal people, to keep the forces of capital at bay.
A politics that requires you to take to the streets for a week is not going to be successful for long and is asking for far too much, even if we think civic virtues are critical and Trump is terrible, and I do think those things.
Of course the early days of trade unions and organization made huge sacrifices, often deadly. So what I would say is this: if we're going to ask people to upend their lives, we do it in a way that builds to something long-term, durable, and can be replicated and repeated and then eventually sets to seize power rather than merely disrupt the system. Have a political project that says, we disrupt the system, and we take control, and here's what we do it with. Make the sacrifice count for more than just to install Mike ****ing Pence. Glibly: if we're gonna take to the streets for a week, how about we simply insist on single payer, or rolling back Right to Work laws, or demanding guaranteed minimum incomes? Treat the sacrifice we're asking from people seriously;
offer them something, a goal to improve their lives measurably. Ironically, I have this gut feeling that if we took the streets and brought the system to a halt to demand single payer, of all the important players in Washington INCLUDING many Democratic elites, it might be Trump that caves first. He's a pliable moron with no principles. If only the GOP Congress were the same.
You and I are probably pretty close in mind, pretty similar in a lot of ways, and if I'm going to march in the streets for a week and risk getting ****canned from work and jail time and whatever else, I want a lot ****ing more than swapping out one crazy right-winger for a different flavor of right-winger. We need to give people more than that.
We want to emulate unscrupulous capitalists here who built stores of wealth and power, but don't work very hard to do it. Politics is the same thing. We want power but we can't ask reasonable, normal people to make life-altering sacrifices in such a reactive way. It's a harder job for normal people, for the working class than the people who have wealth and capital and like everything else, can buy their power with propaganda and co-option. But that's the challenge ahead of us. The challenge of the left going forward IS going to naturally involve a lot of sacrifice and work, and probably very pitched battles that are highly disruptive and not comfortable for all involved. But do it in a way that builds to aggrandizing our own power and can be perpetuated.
I think you know that, so I say this I suppose for no real purpose other than to remind all of us that these kinds of wishes won't really move the needle and remain more fantastical than practical.
Last edited by DVaut1; 07-01-2017 at 10:03 AM.