Quote:
Originally Posted by catfacemeowmers
Your depiction is absolutely correct for my parents. They don't have any affinity for rich people, and they're certainly not rich, but they fume at the idea of a single undeserving person getting government benefits.
It would actually be much better and less morally corrupt if their politics stemmed from self interest rather than animus towards the poor.
Quote:
Originally Posted by aflametotheground
thats more their policies than their stereotypes. its clear that they wanna cut taxes. its not because they care so much for the rich, they probably dont give a damn about the rich (except some corrupt politicians). its more that they cant stand cheaters or undeserving ppl to receive benefits. for us on the left the cheaters are more the rich ppl that are taxed "too low".
i wouldnt fall for such simplistic world views that charicatures are "correct". the world is alot more complex than that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Max Cut
"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer"
--Sir William Blackstone, 1765
"It is better that ten poors starve than that one lazy ass leeches off the state"
--some of my relatives, 2017
I do not know your parents, your relatives, their circumstances, their values, etc. We contain multitudes. Millions of people will genuinely believe a wide array of things. Etc. etc.
That aside, and in general: if modern America and the modern Republican Party with Trump and Fox News at the lead has taught you anything, it's that you should be very, very skeptical about your average right-wingers virtue signaling.
And from there: remember that when a vast majority of right-wingers fume about people cheating the system, and the lazy abusing the welfare state -- they mean black people. Almost exclusively. Sometimes the Venn diagram extends out to other brown people. When they say they can't stand undeserving types, or people cheating the system, or lazy asses leaching -- they mean black people. Cheating or not. Usually you talk to these people long enough and they'll eventually spitball a theory all black people are cheating the system by default, so that being black and cheating the system are basically the same thing. They are triggered specifically by the idea blacks, brown people, and other non-whites are cheating the system and getting things. You can test for this in a myriad of ways but the simplest is simply to take the same people and ask them about affirmative action and see how many get fuming about the exact same things in the exact same ways. Or talk about welfare for 'rural farmers' as opposed to recipients in 'inner cities.' Or any other number of ways right-wingers talk about this in the myriad of coded ways.
I do not mean to indict your relatives but simply recommend you guys get your hackles up and remember most of the people you're talking about aren't actually outraged by people cheating the system. They probably know in their guts that is rare or at least is solvable. They have calculated that fuming about welfare 'cheating' while it may make them look stupid is at least politically acceptable, touches on some shared norms about fairness and good governance. They are not going to tell you what they really think, what they are really opposed to, so you can't take this stuff at face value.
Last edited by DVaut1; 06-29-2017 at 01:51 PM.