Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
As I said earlier, it's not as strange a coalition as you might think. It's not that unusual for a liberal justice to vote with conservative colleagues, or vice versa.
Scalia wrote some very good 4th Amendment decisions. And I'm sure that most posters on this site would disagree with John Paul Stevens's views on flag burning. It really depends on the issue.
SCOTUS decision making is politicized, but less so than most assume.
If a person is very intelligent, prides himself on not being biased, but is in fact biased, he will tend need a decision to be closer before he will go against the better argument, than an average biased person.