Quote:
Originally Posted by Riverman
I was initially turned off by the arrogant tone and inside jokes, but I’ve come around and am now a Chapo fan. Their good content is fantastic. Episode 129 on heath care is way better than anything else I’ve heard on the topic.
Note that the right doesn’t have an equivalent because their policy preferences are wholly unsupportable if you know things.
I've listened to almost every episode. If I wrote serious criticism of Chapo it would look like this:
They don't actually really propose anything. They are for "socialism", whatever that is, they tend not to elaborate. On the episode they had Marxist economics professor Richard Wolff on (ep 186), Wolff said, reasonably, that escaping from feudalism into democracy had required a few bites at the cherry, and was once seen as equally utopian, so it's not surprising that socialism would take a few tries to get right. He allowed that they had learnt some things, like "too much state power is bad", whereupon Will jumped in saying "hang on, state power is also really useful, right?". Meanwhile, Nathan Robinson at Current Affairs is, like Noam Chomsky, a "libertarian socialist" meaning he doesn't support state socialism at all. These people have wildly different political ideologies, they simply share an ethical ideology, and not proposing anything concrete allows them to paper over these differences. To me it's terrifying to think about people who haven't sorted out basic questions like "how much power should the State have and how should that be controlled" having power over anything.
They have a tendency to stereotype when they don't know much about things (although this is partly for comic effect). Matt once described Australia as being the only country comparable to the US in terms of how right-wing it was, using the offshore refugee situation as justification. OK, that's one issue. On virtually everything else - law and order, workplace relations and entitlements, immigration writ large, militarism, education, healthcare, etc etc - Australia is substantially to the left of the US, although to the right of most Western European countries. I'm not reflexively defending Australia here, I hate the place in many ways, but it's like forming an opinion on the US when all you know about it is enhanced interrogation and Guantanamo, let's say.
The positives well outweigh this for me, but yeah.