The whole ITS IN THE CONSTITUTION ethos is just genuflecting to right wing arguments, and it's a perpetual and ever lasting Democratic/liberal/left mistake. See when we try to one-up them on patriotism and felating the military or Christian piety or whatever. They can mercilessly mock war heros and ****, put a porn star on retainer, have 5 kids with 3 women, it doesn't matter, but you better stand for the anthem and you better be God fearing blah blah blah.
Same thing here. The right invented the whole "it's gotta be IN the Constitution" game despite most of them never having read it or even particularly cared about its contents, and they will take out Ouija boards and dream up whatever fantastical **** they want about about Constitutional interpretation and jurisprudence, originalism, intent, who cares, it doesn't matter to the right and it shouldn't matter to anyone else either. It's all made up, bad faith, ad hoc and don't bother with it unless you're a lawyer getting paid to it, it's a fools errand for everyone else to try to keep up with the right on this.
The whole "the Constitution is sacrosanct and you laboriously scan the writings of the people who wrote it and its Amendments is the critical thing that matters the most" rather than its effect on humans is a total right winger bull**** escapade meant to solidify regressive policies. Liberals should never ever play it because Charlie Brown can always pull the football away since it's the right's game and they make all the rules and set all the standards, which is why Donald ****ing Trump is out talking to reporters that it's clearly Constitutional to end birthright citizenship, but hasn't a ****ing clue even why, he isn't even going to pretend to care:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com...w/66454869.cms
Quote:
"Birthright citizenship is a very, very important subject. In my opinion, it's much less complex than people think. I think it says it very loud and clear in the Constitution that you don't have to go through the process of whatever they're talking about," Trump told reporters at the White House on Wednesday.
The reason why we shouldn't stop at "it's in the Constitution" is because it cedes the entire field to the right wing to make up whatever they want. In many ways Donald Trump is much sharper than his opponents because he realized this instinctively. His opponents do cartwheels and flips trying to score the perfectly cited argument and he's like "yeah it's clear as day that the Constitution just says whatever we want obviously and bigly" and their whole base will cheer that on.
The correct argument is that it would actively harm lots of people, the end, put your books away nerds.