Quote:
Originally Posted by 13ball
Yeah, there are no countries that have successfully banned guns.
Correct. There are many countries that don't have gun violence or high gun demand. You need to be incredibly naive to believe it is the laws themselves that prevent gun ownership.
Does the US have a gun problem? Maybe so. Is it the result of laws? Nope. If I had to guess, I would blame large income inequality and rough living conditions in some cities for the prevalence of guns used for violence as well as a culture of guns more strongly embedded than many other places. If you look at murder rates in places with a vibrant middle class and strong economy, you will almost never find them very high.
Sad you can't actually respond to the point. Why do drug laws fail at preventing demand (and usage) but gun laws magically will not?
Quote:
Originally Posted by 13ball
Also another dodge, which is standard. David Gregory just said that they asked 31 pro gun senators to come on Meet the Press this morning and none would.
Oh wow! What a shock that a politician would not want to discuss something incredibly emotionally sensitive at the moment when he can be perceived as heartless by the ignorant fools of the world! Ironically, I probably dislike these same politicians as much as you do but I certainly won't make lame attacks on them like this. Has it ever occurred to you that not endorsing laws against something isn't a sign of support of that thing? I have virtually no experience with drugs. I think heroin is likely one of the most dangerous substances people voluntarily use. Do you really have to be so thick as to assume I actually approve of its usage simply because I don't believe in criminalizing it? There are tons of things I feel are abhorrent but practically speaking, if there is a demand there will be a supply, and morally speaking, I have no right to tell an individual what they can and cannot do with themselves. The law becomes justified (although still isn't a large preventative action) when an individual encroaches on the freedom of innocent third party. Hence, guns, knives, fists, you name it can all be legal, while using any of those things to harm someone certainly should be illegal. But again don't fool yourself into believing it is murder laws that somehow stop murder etc etc. They are justified in their existence, but they are not the savior you want to believe. Have a strong economy and a vibrant middle class is probably your first best line of defense against a lot of violent crime. There are certainly other cultural and societal things that can influence it, but it's a great starting point. Oh, and as you can see in this film (
http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/41...taboo-1276607/) it is the same do gooder law loving attitude used toward drugs that has caused an INSANE amount of gun violence in this world. Creating a black market will increase violence, not decrease it.
Last edited by insidemanpoker; 12-16-2012 at 11:44 AM.