Let's talk that Kraft prostitution arrest. Here's how Business Insider
reported it at the time:
Quote:
New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft's prostitution charges on Friday were part of a bust for what police said was a large-scale human-trafficking and prostitution ring in Florida.
Within the ring, women were trafficked and coerced into working as prostitutes in 10 different spas and massage parlors, according to the Vero Beach Police Department.
The victims were forced to live in the spas for days, sometimes months, "for the purpose of sexual servitude," according to the charges. Many of them came from China on temporary work visas, believing they'd get legitimate jobs in the US, Vero Beach Police Chief David Currey said in a press conference.
"These girls are there all day long, into the evening. They can't leave and they're performing sex acts," he said. "Some of them may tell us they're OK, but they're not."
The police did not identify the number of women considered to be victims in the trafficking ring. Authorities charged at least 173 people with crimes, including human trafficking and soliciting prostitution. Six people are charged with running the ring.
I'm now going to quote heavily from a series of articles written by Elizabeth Nolan Brown (
1,
2,
3) in Reason.
So. People were arrested for trafficking. Right? It says so right in the Insider article.
Quote:
At a press conference (partially aired on CNN) today, Palm Beach District Attorney Dave Aronberg spent most of his time talking about the theoretical horrors that could occur in situations like this. "Modern day slavery," as Aronberg called it, "can happen anywhere, including in the peaceful community of Jupiter."
However, no human trafficking charges were filed among the hundreds of (current and coming) prostitution charges, he admitted, adding that first-time offenders (like Robert Kraft) are "very unlikely to get any significant" time behind bars.
"There's no allegation that any defendant engaged in human trafficking," said Aronberg.
Quote:
Police from Vero Beach said in a press release that one woman had been arrested for human trafficking, and Florida news outlets are still running with that story. But a simple check of county court records shows that this is not the case. Like her colleagues, the woman is charged with engaging in prostitution herself, "deriving support" from prostitution, and "racketeering," which sounds serious but just means working with others to accomplish something illegal.
It should be noted that the police have weeks of surveillance footage from hidden cameras at this establishment. If they're not bringing trafficking or abuse charges, it's because there isn't evidence of trafficking or abuse.
But the women are very grateful for having been rescued?
Quote:
Police keep calling the women that worked at Orchids of Asia and the other spas that were part of the sting "trafficking victims." But most have declined to cooperate with police as such.
Martin County Sheriff Snyder told CNN today that police were having trouble getting one woman in custody to "cooperate" in explaining why they would "go and allow themselves to be trafficked."
"They had the ability, they could've walked out into the street and asked for help," he continued, noting that they often worked long hours and cooked food on a hot-plate instead of leaving for meals. "But they didn't."
Instead of taking this as a sign that these women were willingly engaging in this work, police continue to seek ways to explain away this evidence. (And the CNN host asked why they wouldn't "speak their truth.") Snyder claims that one woman said she was afraid people might hurt her family if she cooperated.
This type of claim is made regularly by police in these sorts of investigations. That is convenient, considering they're the only ones allowed to talk to any of the alleged victims and it's an explanation no one can verify, unlike initial claims from law enforcement—now countered by Synder—that massage parlor workers weren't allowed to leave.
But they were working under horrific conditions. Right?
Quote:
Police have suggested that "victims" at these businesses were sexually serving 1,500 men per year. But according to arrest documents, their cameras caught an average of about one sexual customer per employee every three days.
Those that were arrested stand accused of engaging in between 3 and 16 paid sex acts apiece throughout the 40-day surveillance period.
Police originally relied on two details to spin the trafficking narrative in the press: Some of the women were living at the massage parlors, and they "weren't allowed to leave." But Martin County Sheriff William Snyder later admitted that the part about not being allowed to leave was false.
Included as evidence that they lived there was the presence of "food and condiments" in a kitchen fridge—pretty standard for workplace kitchens, no? In addition, one of the places had two extra rooms, in which police found beds made with sheets and pillows and dressers holding personal belongings. Police later told reporters these women were sleeping on "cots" and in "squalor," but that's not what their official report says.
So basically, everything the police have said to the media on the subject is self-serving lies, designed to evoke moral outrage from a public who doesn't really care about vanilla prostitution. Law enforcement telling fibs? I'm shocked.
Sex trafficking is unquestionably going on in the US, but what is the scale of the problem? To me this has the shape of a moral panic (like "Stranger Danger" back in the day, where allegedly huge numbers of kids were being abducted by strangers). It's because:
- Trafficking is, like terrorism, a way to combine disparate incidents into a whole that you can present to people as a huge, terrifying problem necessitating drastic action. Like terrorism, laws intended to stop this problem will inevitably be applied to situations they weren't meant for.
- Not many people want to die on the hill of pushing back against this issue, it makes you look like a callous monster.
- Everyone involved here - advocates, police and the media - have huge incentives to exaggerate the scale of the problem. Nobody has an incentive to downplay it.
Meanwhile, the women caught up in the sting are sitting in state jail, awaiting trial for prostitution. If the state's interest in this case is the welfare of these women, they have a funny way of showing it.